| Course | ACC 260 Management Accounting |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Sunk cost discussion post |
| Length | About 470 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 260 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Ignore the $18,000: Why the Old Press's Book Value Has No Place in the Replacement Decision
Initial Post
The old press's remaining book value of $18,000 should be ignored in deciding whether to replace it.
What should be counted instead are the future cash flows that differ between keeping the old press and buying the new one.
In the illustrative case, a print shop can buy a new press for $40,000. The old press would sell for $6,000 today. The new press would save $9,000 a year in ink, maintenance and labor over a five-year life, and neither press is expected to be worth anything at the end. Each figure, with its status:
New press cost, $40,000: relevant, because it is paid only if the shop replaces.
Sale of the old press today, $6,000: relevant, because it is received only if the shop replaces.
Annual savings, $9,000 for five years: relevant, because they occur only with the new press.
Book value of the old press, $18,000: not relevant, because it reflects money spent years ago that no choice made today can recover.
Counting only the relevant figures, replacement brings in $45,000 of savings and $6,000 from the sale against $40,000 paid, a net gain of $11,000 over five years. Discounted at 8%, the savings are worth about $35,934 today, and the gain is about $1,934, smaller but still positive. Relevant costs are future costs that differ between alternatives, and a sunk cost is neither (Garrison et al., 2021).
I understand why the owner wants to count the $18,000. Selling a press carried at $18,000 for $6,000 produces a $12,000 loss on the income statement, and writing it off feels like admitting the original purchase was a mistake. Across several experiments, Arkes and Blumer (1985) found that people keep putting resources into a course of action because of what they have already spent, even when the past spending should not affect the choice. That is a behavioral pull, not an accounting argument. The $12,000 loss is simply the recognition, now, of value that was already gone.
Reply to Morgan
Morgan, I agree with your conclusion to replace, but I would press on one figure. You counted the old press's annual depreciation of $3,600 as a saving if the shop replaces. Depreciation is the old press's $18,000 book value spread over its remaining five years, so counting it is counting the sunk cost again in smaller pieces. It is not a cash flow in either alternative, apart from its tax effect, which our problem sets aside. If you remove it, your net gain falls from $29,000 to $11,000, and the case for replacing is thinner than your post suggests, especially after discounting. Would your recommendation hold if the savings came in at $7,000 a year instead of $9,000?
References
Arkes, H. R., & Blumer, C. (1985). The psychology of sunk cost. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 35(1), 124-140. https://doi.org/10.1016/0749-5978(85)90049-4
Garrison, R. H., Noreen, E. W., & Brewer, P. C. (2021). Managerial accounting (17th ed.). McGraw Hill.
Reading the GCU ACC 260 Topic 5 instructions
ACC-260 Topic 5 asks students to discuss sunk costs in a replacement decision. Many posts define a sunk cost and stop. The prompt rewards posts that state a position at once, work a numerical comparison with each figure labeled relevant or not relevant and a reason, and show the net effect with and without discounting. Students should acknowledge why owners are drawn to the sunk cost, distinguishing a behavioral pull from an accounting argument, and include a reply that challenges a specific figure a classmate treated as relevant rather than simply agreeing.
How this ACC 260 Topic 5 example is built
The finished post takes a side before it explains anything. Its opening sentence says the old press's remaining book value should be ignored, and its second says what should be counted instead. The body works one illustrative comparison in a few lines: the new press costs $40,000, the old one would sell for $6,000 today, and the new one saves $9,000 a year in ink, maintenance and labor over a five-year life. Each figure is labeled relevant or not, with its reason given in a single clause. The post acknowledges why the owner wants to count the $18,000, since writing it off feels like admitting a mistake, and it names that as a behavioral pull rather than an accounting argument. A reply to a classmate follows, pressing on one cost the classmate treated as relevant.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 260 Topic 5 rubric
GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards relevant costs identified correctly. Excellent posts count the new press cost, the sale of the old press and the savings, and exclude book value with a clear reason. Credit goes to computing the net gain and testing it with discounting. The rubric values explaining the reluctance to book a loss, supported by research on sunk cost behavior. The strongest replies show that counting old depreciation brings the sunk cost back in smaller pieces and ask a classmate to test a lower savings figure. Posts that include book value in the comparison tend to earn partial credit.
ACC 260 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Discussion posts in this topic tend to lose marks for agreeing with the principle and then breaking it. A response stating that sunk costs are irrelevant, followed by a comparison that subtracts the remaining book value anyway, has recited the rule and failed to apply it. Posts discarding every past figure go wrong in the other direction, since resale value is available now and belongs in the decision even though it relates to the old press. Treating depreciation on the old machine as a saving from replacement double counts the sunk amount. Opening with a definition of relevant cost delays the position until a classmate has stopped reading. Replies that say they agree and add nothing earn little, because the rubric in most sections looks for an exchange that tests a figure somebody actually used.
Get an ACC-260 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-260 Topic 5 DQ prompt exactly as posted, the discussion rubric and any figures in the scenario. The custom example comes back written to them, with the position in the first line, every figure labeled relevant or not, the sunk amount handled correctly and a reply that tests a classmate's number, ready in 24 to 48 hours. The first sample is free.
More ACC 260 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 260 Topic 1: Reporting Audience Comparison
- ACC 260 Topic 2: Cost Behavior Classification
- ACC 260 Topic 3: Contribution Format Restatement
- ACC 260 Topic 4: Break-even Assumptions Memo
- ACC 260 Topic 6: Linked Budget Schedules
- ACC 260 Topic 7: Make-or-buy Decision Analysis
- ACC 260 Topic 8: Keep or Drop Recommendation
- ACC 335 Topic 5: Control Cost Discussion Post
- ACC 250 Topic 5: Note Disclosure Discussion Post
- ACC 337 Topic 5: Pattern Versus Evidence Dq Post
- ACC 240 Topic 5: Undetected Error Discussion Post
ACC 260 Topic 5 questions, answered
Is resale value a sunk cost too?
No. It relates to an asset bought in the past, but it is an amount the company can receive now and will forgo if it keeps the machine, so it differs between the options. That makes it relevant. The purchase price and the book value are the sunk figures, because nothing decided today can change what was paid or what has been recorded.
Should the post use present value?
Only if the course has introduced it or the prompt asks. At this level a comparison of undiscounted totals is normal, provided the post says it has not discounted and names the direction the adjustment would push. Savings arriving over five years are worth less than the price paid today, so discounting narrows the advantage, and saying so shows judgment without adding a calculation.
Why do managers keep counting sunk costs?
Partly because performance is often measured on the statements, and a loss on disposal lands in the year a manager replaces the asset. Partly because nobody likes to record that a purchase aged badly. A strong post names that incentive, since it explains the behavior the DQ is describing, and then shows that the relevant comparison is unaffected by it.
Where can I find a free ACC 260 Topic 5 sample paper?
The full initial post and reply are above: the position, the illustrative press, each figure labeled, the net gain with and without discounting, the behavioral pull and a reply on depreciation. Share the discussion question for a free example with a reply.
Why is the old press's book value ignored in ACC 260 Topic 5?
It reflects money spent years ago that no choice made now can recover, so it is the same whether the shop keeps the press or replaces it.