ACC 335 Topic 5 control cost discussion post example

Accounting Information Systems Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 335 Topic 5 sample discussion post opens with its position: a food bank should require two signatures on checks above $2,500, one below, and a monthly treasurer review of every disbursement. It was written for GCU ACC 335, Accounting Information Systems, catalog code ACC-335, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Accounting. The post prices dual signatures on all 60 monthly checks, which would delay recurring bills and invite pre-signed blank checks, and names the risk the second signature addresses, an unauthorized or fictitious payment. It argues a detective review covers small checks for less effort, and a reply tests whether a classmate's board approval plan would survive December.

CourseACC 335 Accounting Information Systems
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeControl cost discussion post
LengthAbout 460 words, 1 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 335 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply

Two Signatures Above $2,500, One Below, and a Monthly Review of Every Check: Pricing a Control Before Requiring It

Initial Post

My position: the food bank should require two signatures on checks above $2,500, one signature below that, and a monthly review of every disbursement by the treasurer.

The prompt proposes two signatures on every check. Before adopting it, it is worth pricing. In this illustrative case the food bank writes about 60 checks a month. Around 45 are recurring and predictable: rent, utilities, payroll tax deposits, insurance and the regular grocery wholesaler. The second signer must be a volunteer board member, and board members work day jobs. In practice, a second signature on every check means payments wait days for a signer, late fees start to appear, and staff begin asking board members to sign blank checks in advance so bills can be paid on time. At that point the control is worse than none, because the organization believes it has a safeguard it no longer has.

The risk the second signature addresses is an unauthorized or fictitious payment: a check to a vendor that does not exist, or a legitimate vendor paid for goods never received. Payment tampering of this kind is a recognized fraud scheme (Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, 2024). Above $2,500, where about eight checks a month fall, a single loss would be large for an organization this size, so the delay of a second signature is worth it. Below $2,500, a detective control catches the same problem for far less effort: the treasurer receives the bank statement directly, with check images, and reviews every payment against the vendor list and the approved budget each month.

The internal control framework expects controls to provide reasonable assurance, not absolute assurance, and recognizes that their costs should be weighed against their benefits (Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission, 2013). A control that staff route around in the first busy month provides neither.

Reply to Jordan

Jordan, your proposal to have the full board approve every check at its monthly meeting would give strong authorization, but I am not sure it would survive a busy month. The board meets on the third Thursday. A utility bill due on the 5th would wait almost two weeks past its due date, and payroll tax deposits have fixed deadlines with penalties. In December, when the food bank's purchasing doubles, the list of checks awaiting approval would grow to a hundred or more, and a board reviewing that many items in one evening is likely to approve them in a block without reading them. Would you consider board approval of the monthly budget and vendor list instead, with the treasurer reviewing individual payments against both?

References

Association of Certified Fraud Examiners. (2024). Occupational fraud 2024: A report to the nations. https://legacy.acfe.com/report-to-the-nations/2024/

Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission. (2013). Internal control: Integrated framework. COSO.

The ACC-335 Topic 5 assignment instructions

ACC-335 Topic 5 asks students to discuss the cost and benefit of internal controls. Many posts endorse a control without asking what it costs. Strong responses open with a clear stance, then price the proposed control in the organization's actual conditions, name the specific risk the control addresses and compare a preventive control with a detective one that covers the same risk. Students should explain how an unworkable control is routed around, connect the argument to the idea of reasonable assurance, and reply to a classmate by testing whether their control would survive a busy period.

How the ACC-335 Topic 5 example is put together

The finished post states its position in its opening sentence: two signatures above a threshold, one below it, and a monthly review of every disbursement. It then prices the alternative the DQ proposed. In the illustrative case, the nonprofit writes about sixty checks a month, most of them rent, utilities and payroll taxes, and each second signature needs a volunteer board member to be available, which delays payments and invites signing blank checks in advance to keep bills current. The post names the risk the second signature addresses, an unauthorized or fictitious payment, and argues that above the threshold the exposure justifies the delay while below it a detective review catches the same problem for a fraction of the effort. A reply to a classmate follows, testing whether their proposed control would survive a busy month.

Reading the ACC 335 Topic 5 rubric

GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards controls weighed against their cost. Excellent posts count the checks, identify which are recurring and show how universal dual signatures would lead to delays and pre-signed checks. Credit goes to setting a threshold where the exposure justifies the delay and a review below it. The rubric values reference to reasonable assurance and cost-benefit in the control framework. The strongest replies test a classmate's plan against a real calendar and propose a workable alternative. Posts that call every control worthwhile regardless of cost tend to earn partial credit.

Common ACC 335 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Posts that call for more controls without asking what they cost to run tend to earn the least here. Endorsing two signatures on every check is the safe-sounding answer, and it ignores what the DQ is really asking, which is whether the organization can sustain the rule. The opposite answer, dismissing the control as bureaucracy, fails for the same reason in reverse, since it never names the risk it is accepting. Costing a control in dollars only, when the real cost is a volunteer's availability and several days of delayed payments, misses what makes it fail. Posts that recommend a threshold without explaining what covers the payments below it have left a gap unexamined. Replies that approve of a classmate's answer in general, with no question about its cost or its risk, add nothing a reader could respond to.

Get an ACC-335 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-335 Topic 5 DQ prompt as your classroom shows it, the discussion rubric and any organization details provided. A custom example is written to them, with the position stated first, the risk named, the control priced in time and delay, the remaining exposure admitted and a reply that tests a classmate's cost, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More ACC 335 papers and BS in Accounting samples

ACC 335 Topic 5 questions, answered

How do I put a cost on a control?

Count what it consumes: staff or volunteer time per transaction, delay introduced into the process, software or fees, and the workarounds it provokes when people are busy. Then compare that with the exposure it addresses, meaning how large a loss could be and how likely it is without the control. Figures in a DQ can be illustrative, provided they are labeled that way and kept consistent.

Is a detective control weaker than a preventive one?

It works differently. A preventive control stops the transaction; a detective control finds it afterward, which limits the loss to whatever happens before the review. For low-value, high-volume payments a detective control is often the better trade, because it is cheap to run and hard to bypass. It only works if the reviewer is independent and actually looks.

Should the reply disagree with the classmate?

Not necessarily, but it should test something. Asking what a classmate's proposed control would cost to operate in a busy month, or which specific payment it would stop, gives them something to answer and moves the thread along. A reply that simply agrees gives the thread nowhere to go, and most discussion rubrics reward the exchange itself.

Where can I find a free ACC 335 Topic 5 sample paper?

Both the post and a reply appear on this page, covering the stated position, the cost of universal dual signatures, the risk addressed, the threshold and review, reasonable assurance and a reply testing a board approval plan. Share the discussion question for a free worked post.

Why not require two signatures on every check in ACC 335 Topic 5?

Most of the 60 monthly checks are recurring bills, and waiting for a volunteer second signer delays them and tempts staff to have blank checks signed in advance.