BUS 676 Topic 5 stakeholder conflict dq post example

Advanced Conscious Capitalism: Free Market Perspectives Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This BUS 676 Topic 5 sample paper is a discussion post taking a position on who should decide when stakeholder interests conflict, followed by a response to one classmate. The post was written for GCU BUS 676, Advanced Conscious Capitalism: Free Market Perspectives, catalog code BUS-676, part of the Grand Canyon University MS in Leadership. A composite furniture maker could move 340 upholstery jobs from a North Carolina town to Mexico, protecting 1,600 other jobs. Research on displaced workers shows the losses last for years. The post compares stakeholder balancing, Jensen's value tiebreaker and Friedman's owner wishes, then proposes a rule owners set in advance with costs disclosed and mitigated.

CourseBUS 676 Advanced Conscious Capitalism: Free Market Perspectives
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeDiscussion post and reply
LengthAbout 480 words, 3 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Leadership
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for BUS 676 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply

When Waiting Does Not Reconcile the Interests: Who Decides a Plant Move, and the Rule That Should Have Been Set Before It Came Up

Initial Post

The board decides, and any doctrine that cannot say by what rule the board should decide has not answered the question.

Here is a conflict that time does not fix. A composite upholstered-furniture maker employs 340 people at a plant in a small North Carolina town, where it is the largest private employer. Moving upholstery to a plant it already owns in Mexico would save an illustrative $9 million a year and protect the company's other 1,600 jobs against cheaper competitors. Shareholders gain, customers probably get steadier prices and most employees keep more secure jobs. The 340 lose, and the median worker there is 52. Workers who lose long-held jobs in mass layoffs earn substantially less for years afterward, with the shortfall still large six years on (Jacobson et al., 1993), so there is no plausible horizon at which these workers are made whole.

Three answers are on offer. Stakeholder theory in its normative form asks managers to balance the groups' interests (Freeman, 1984), but it gives no rule for this balance, so a manager could defend either choice. Jensen's enlightened value maximization says long-run firm value is the tiebreaker, while requiring attention to every group whose cooperation the firm needs (Jensen, 2001). Friedman says the owners' wishes decide, within law and ethical custom (Friedman, 1970). The second and third at least tell us who is accountable and by what measure; the first leaves the decision to whoever is in the room.

My proposal is a middle course. The owners should adopt a decision rule in advance, before any particular move is on the table: for example, the company will relocate work when the savings are large and lasting, but it will fund severance, retraining and job placement at a level it discloses, and it will give the town at least a year's notice. The stakeholder costs are then disclosed and mitigated rather than ignored or used as a veto, and investors, employees and towns can see the rule before they commit to the company.

What this page is doingThe post takes a position in its first sentence, sets out a conflict that no time horizon resolves and compares three answers by whether they say who is accountable.
2

Reply to Marisol

Marisol, you argued that in the long run the move serves everyone, because a more competitive company will grow and hire again in the region. I agree that is possible, and your point about the other 1,600 jobs is the strongest part of the case for moving. But the people who lose their jobs at 52 are not the people who might be hired in ten years, and the long run may not include them at all. If we have to wait an unspecified time for the conflict to disappear, the claim cannot be tested. What horizon would you accept as a test, and what would you conclude if the displaced workers were still worse off at the end of it?

What this page is doingThe reply accepts the strongest part of the classmate's case before asking for a specific horizon, which turns a general claim into something testable.
3

References

Freeman, R. E. (1984). Strategic management: A stakeholder approach. Pitman.

Friedman, M. (1970, September 13). The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits. The New York Times Magazine, 32-33, 122-126.

Jacobson, L. S., LaLonde, R. J., & Sullivan, D. G. (1993). Earnings losses of displaced workers. American Economic Review, 83(4), 685-709.

Jensen, M. C. (2001). Value maximization, stakeholder theory, and the corporate objective function. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 14(3), 8-21. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-6622.2001.tb00434.x

BUS 676 Topic 5 instructions, in plain terms

In BUS-676 Topic 5 the discussion question asks how a firm should resolve a conflict among stakeholders. Posts that say interests align in the long run avoid the question. The prompt rewards a clear position on who decides and by what rule, applied to a conflict detailed enough to argue about. Students should explain why no plausible time horizon resolves the case, compare the main answers by whether they assign accountability and propose a workable approach. The reply should engage a classmate's argument, accept its strongest part and ask a question that moves the discussion forward. Citing the positions summarized is expected at graduate level.

How the BUS-676 Topic 5 example is put together

The initial post opens by stating that the board decides and needs a rule. The plant move is set out with the gains, the losses and research on displaced workers' earnings. Three answers are compared, with stakeholder balancing criticized for leaving no criterion. The post then proposes a decision rule adopted in advance, with severance, retraining and notice disclosed. The reply to Marisol accepts that the move protects other jobs, then points out that those displaced are not those who might be hired later and asks what horizon would count as a test. Four sources support the post.

Where the marks sit in the BUS 676 Topic 5 rubric

Faculty grading the discussion reward a position stated in the first sentence and defended with a concrete conflict. The best posts show why waiting will not reconcile the interests, with evidence rather than assertion. Credit goes to comparing answers by whether they say who is accountable and by what measure. The rubric values a proposal that discloses and mitigates costs without letting them become a veto. Excellent replies accept the strongest part of a classmate's view and then ask for a testable horizon or standard. Posts that rely on the long run to dissolve the conflict usually lose marks. Citations for each position summarized also count.

BUS 676 Topic 5 help before you submit

Discussion credit here tends to vanish when a post dissolves the conflict instead of deciding it. Asserting that customers, owners and workers all benefit eventually lets the post avoid the question of who chooses, which the prompt poses directly. Posts saying the manager should balance everyone's interests, and stopping there, repeat the doctrine's weakest answer without examining it. The free-market positions lose marks when reduced to greed, since Friedman and Jensen each specify a rule and an accountable party, which is the substance of their critique. Positions stated with no cost acknowledged read as advocacy, however sympathetic the side they take. Replies that merely agree, or that restate the initial post in other words, forfeit the engagement credit discussion rubrics typically reward, and a thread in which nobody's view moves has not been a discussion.

Get a BUS-676 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the BUS-676 Topic 5 discussion question as your classroom words it, with the participation rubric and any classmate post you are answering. We write a custom example to those criteria, with a position on who decides, three answers stated fairly, the position's cost granted and a reply marking where an objection runs out, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More BUS 676 papers and MS in Leadership samples

BUS 676 Topic 5 questions, answered

Doesn't stakeholder theory say managers should balance interests?

Many versions do, and the post treats that as a real answer rather than a slogan. The difficulty is that balancing, without a rule for how much weight each group receives, leaves the manager able to justify almost any outcome. That is the accountability objection free-market critics press. A strong post states the balancing view fairly and then asks what would make a particular balance wrong.

Is it acceptable to side with the shareholders?

Yes, if the argument supports it and the post takes the costs seriously. Friedman's position, stated properly, requires compliance with law and ethical custom and leaves owners free to choose goals beyond profit. A post defending owner authority can still insist on honest disclosure and fair treatment of displaced workers. What loses credit is siding with anyone by caricaturing the alternative.

Does the post need citations?

Follow what your discussion rubric requires, and at graduate level expect to cite the positions you summarize. Friedman's 1970 essay, Freeman on stakeholder management and Jensen on the single objective are natural sources for this prompt. Summarize each accurately, and where a claim comes from a textbook rather than the original, cite the textbook, since secondary summaries of Friedman in particular are often wrong.

Where can I find a free BUS 676 Topic 5 sample paper?

The initial post on the plant move and the reply to Marisol are both above, with notes in the margin on each step. Send the prompt and the conflict you want to discuss, and a free post on your own case can be drafted.

What rule does the post propose in BUS 676 Topic 5?

That owners adopt a decision rule before any move is on the table: relocate work when savings are large and lasting, but fund severance, retraining and placement at a disclosed level and give the town a year's notice.