DBA 805 Topic 2 theory appraisal criteria paper example

Management Theory in a Global Economy Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DBA 805 Topic 2 sample paper writes six criteria for appraising theories before naming any theory, then pilots them on upper echelons and structural contingency theory. It belongs to GCU DBA 805, Management Theory in a Global Economy, listed as DBA-805 within Grand Canyon University's Doctor of Business Administration. Four criteria come from Whetten's building blocks and two from Bacharach, with mechanism and falsifiability double weighted. Upper echelons edges ahead 25 to 24 weighted, while equal weights reverse the order to 19 against 20, and the paper reports that reversal openly. The criterion the writer is least sure of, utility, is named last.

CourseDBA 805 Management Theory in a Global Economy
TopicTopic 2
Paper typeTheory appraisal criteria paper
LengthAbout 1,020 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DBA 805 Topic 2

1

Six Criteria Written Before Any Theory Is Named: An Appraisal Instrument, Piloted on Upper Echelons and Structural Contingency, That Reports Its Own Reversal

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

DBA-805: Management Theory in a Global Economy

Topic 2 Theory Appraisal Criteria Paper

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the instrument's safeguard and the finding it discloses.
2

Six Criteria Written Before Any Theory Is Named: An Appraisal Instrument, Piloted on Upper Echelons and Structural Contingency, That Reports Its Own Reversal

Why the Criteria Come First

An instrument for appraising theories is only trustworthy if it was written before the theories it judges were in view; criteria drafted with a favored theory in mind tend to crown it. This paper therefore states six criteria, weights them and dates them before naming any theory. Each criterion is posed as a question a theory could fail, with an example of a failing theory drawn from outside the pilot. Only then are two theories scored, and the weighting is tested by rescoring without it.

Four Criteria From Whetten

Whetten (1989) described the building blocks of a theoretical contribution as what, how, why, and who, where and when. These become four criteria. Constructs: does the theory name its concepts precisely enough that two researchers would measure the same thing? Early writing on employee engagement often failed this test, using one term for several distinct states. Relationships: does it state how the constructs relate, including direction? The Hawthorne effect, as commonly invoked, fails it, asserting that attention changes behavior without saying in which direction or for whom. Mechanism: does it explain why the relationship should hold? Claims of first-mover advantage often fail it, asserting that early entrants win without specifying the process. Boundaries: does it state for whom, where and when it applies? Maslow's hierarchy, presented as universal, fails it.

Two Criteria From Bacharach

Bacharach (1989) argued that theories should be judged on falsifiability and utility. Falsifiability: could some observation show the theory wrong? Priem and Butler (2001) argued that the resource-based view, in its common form, risks failing this test, since a resource is defined as valuable partly by the advantage it is supposed to explain. Utility: does the theory help explain and predict in ways a practitioner or researcher can use? Population ecology, which treats organizational change as selection rather than adaptation, offers managers little they can act on, and so scores low on this criterion even where its explanations are strong.

Weighting

Mechanism and falsifiability carry double weight, and the others single weight. The reason is the purpose of the instrument: a doctoral program judges theories as knowledge, and a theory that explains why and could be shown wrong is worth more as knowledge than one that is merely precise or useful. Scores run from 1 to 5 on every criterion, giving a weighted maximum of 40. The weights, criteria and scoring rules were recorded on the first day of the exercise, before the pilot theories were chosen.

The Pilot

Two theories were chosen because the writer expected them to rank differently, which makes a biased instrument easier to detect: upper echelons theory and structural contingency theory. Upper echelons theory proposes that organizations reflect the cognitive bases and values of their top managers, observable through demographic characteristics such as age, tenure and functional background (Hambrick & Mason, 1984). Structural contingency theory proposes that organizations perform better when their structure fits contingencies such as size, technology and environmental uncertainty (Donaldson, 2001).

Table 1

Pilot Scores on Six Criteria

CriterionWeightUpper echelonsStructural contingency
Constructs143
Relationships144
Mechanism232
Boundaries134
Falsifiability232
Utility125
Weighted total, out of 40| 2524
Equal-weight total, out of 30| 1920

Justifying the Scores

Upper echelons theory names its constructs and their relationships clearly and scores 4 on each. Its mechanism, managerial cognition, is plausible but usually observed only through demographic proxies, so the theory's central process is rarely tested directly; it scores 3 on mechanism and 3 on falsifiability. Its boundaries are partly specified, 3, and its practical utility is limited, 2, since firms cannot easily change executives' backgrounds. Structural contingency theory states relationships between contingencies and structure clearly, 4, and its boundaries are well developed, 4, but its central construct, fit, is often identified after performance is known, which weakens both its mechanism, 2, and its falsifiability, 2. Its utility is high, 5, because it tells managers what structure to adopt for their situation.

Is the Weighting a Verdict in Disguise?

The obvious objection is that weighting smuggles in the conclusion. The instrument answers it by rescoring with equal weights. Weighted, upper echelons theory edges ahead, 25 to 24; with equal weights, structural contingency theory leads, 20 to 19. The ranking reverses, and the paper reports that openly. The reversal shows exactly what the weighting does: it favors theories that explain and could fail over theories that are precise and useful. Readers who reject that priority will rank the theories differently, and they can see why.

What the Pilot Shows About the Instrument

The pilot's purpose was to test the instrument, not to crown a theory, and it shows two useful things. The criteria discriminate: the two theories score differently on four of the six, so the instrument is not simply rewarding familiarity. And the scores cluster in the middle, between 2 and 5, which suggests the scale has room above and below for theories that are much stronger or weaker. A further pilot should add a theory from a different tradition, such as institutional theory, to check whether the instrument is biased against theories whose mechanisms are social rather than economic.

The Criterion the Writer Is Least Sure Of

The writer is least sure of the utility criterion. Utility depends on who is using the theory and for what, and a single score cannot represent both a researcher choosing a study framework and a manager choosing a structure. A future version of the instrument might score utility separately for each audience.

Conclusion

Written before any theory was named, the six criteria turn Whetten's building blocks and Bacharach's tests into questions a theory can fail, and the weights state openly what the instrument values. Piloted on two theories expected to differ, it discriminates between them, and rescoring without weights reverses their order. Reporting that reversal, rather than hiding it, is what lets a reader trust the instrument's other judgments.

References

Bacharach, S. B. (1989). Organizational theories: Some criteria for evaluation. Academy of Management Review, 14(4), 496-515. https://doi.org/10.2307/258555

Donaldson, L. (2001). The contingency theory of organizations. Sage.

Hambrick, D. C., & Mason, P. A. (1984). Upper echelons: The organization as a reflection of its top managers. Academy of Management Review, 9(2), 193-206. https://doi.org/10.2307/258434

Priem, R. L., & Butler, J. E. (2001). Is the resource-based "view" a useful perspective for strategic management research? Academy of Management Review, 26(1), 22-40. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2001.4011928

Whetten, D. A. (1989). What constitutes a theoretical contribution? Academy of Management Review, 14(4), 490-495. https://doi.org/10.2307/258554

The DBA-805 Topic 2 assignment instructions

The Topic 2 assignment in DBA-805 asks doctoral students to build criteria for appraising theory and test them. Strong papers write and weight the criteria before any theory is named, pose each criterion as a question a theory could fail with an example drawn from outside the pilot, and justify the weighting by the purpose of the appraisal. Students should pilot the instrument on theories expected to rank differently, justify every score in prose, test whether the weighting decides the result and report any reversal rather than hiding it. The pilot theories should come from different traditions where possible, so that bias against one tradition becomes visible.

How the DBA-805 Topic 2 example is put together

Six criteria appear in the finished paper before a single theory is named, each with a question and a failing answer. Four come from Whetten's building blocks: the constructs a theory names, how they relate, why the relationship should hold, and the who, where and when that bound it. Two come from Bacharach: falsifiability and utility. Mechanism and falsifiability carry double weight, and the paper says why, since a doctoral program is judging theories as knowledge rather than as tools. The pilot follows. Upper echelons theory, from Hambrick and Mason, scores well on constructs and relationships but weakly on falsifiability of its mechanism, because demographic proxies stand in for the cognition it theorizes. Structural contingency scores high on utility and low on falsifiability, where fit is often identified after performance is known.

DBA 805 Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward an instrument built before it is used. An Excellent paper derives four criteria from Whetten and two from Bacharach, each with a failing example such as the tautology Priem and Butler identified. Credit goes to defending double weight for mechanism and falsifiability. The rubric values a pilot table scoring Hambrick and Mason's upper echelons theory against Donaldson's structural contingency theory with every score justified. Strong papers rescore with equal weights. Top marks go to reporting the reversal and the least certain criterion.

DBA 805 Topic 2 help before you submit

Criteria drafted with a favored theory already in mind cost the most here, and a pilot that crowns one theory on every row is the usual evidence. Listing Whetten's questions without turning them into criteria a theory could fail leaves the instrument descriptive. Papers that weight nothing imply that utility and falsifiability matter equally, a position they rarely defend and doctoral readers rarely accept. Some omit the pilot entirely, so the criteria are never shown to discriminate between theories. Others pilot on two theories from one tradition, which cannot reveal bias against the other traditions. Hiding a weighting sensitivity is worse than having one, and a paper that reports its own reversal earns trust the rest of the argument can spend.

Get a DBA-805 Topic 2 example written to your instructions

Send the DBA-805 Topic 2 instructions and the rubric your section posted, plus any theories or criteria the prompt names. We write a custom example to them, with criteria fixed and weighted before any theory appears, a pilot on two theories expected to rank differently, and the weighting objection tested openly, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More DBA 805 papers and DBA samples

DBA 805 Topic 2 questions, answered

What are Whetten's building blocks of theory?

David Whetten proposed that a complete theory answers four sets of questions: what factors it includes, how they relate, why the relationships should hold, and who, where and when they apply. The last set marks a theory's boundary conditions. The example converts each block into a criterion with a failing answer, so a theory can be judged on it rather than merely described through it.

What criteria did Bacharach propose?

Samuel Bacharach argued that organizational theories should be evaluated chiefly on falsifiability and utility. Falsifiability concerns whether the theory is constructed so that it could be refuted; utility concerns whether it explains and predicts in a way that is useful. The example adopts both, weights falsifiability double alongside mechanism, and explains that choice before any theory is scored, so the weighting cannot be tuned to a result.

Why pilot the criteria on two theories?

A set of criteria is an instrument, and an instrument has to show it can discriminate before its readings mean anything. Piloting on two theories the writer expects to rank differently exposes a set that quietly favors one, since a biased instrument gives the same theory the top score everywhere. In the example each theory fails at least two criteria, which is the evidence that the set sorts rather than flatters.

Where can I find a free DBA 805 Topic 2 sample paper?

The appraisal paper is printed here in full: why criteria come first, four criteria from Whetten, two from Bacharach, weighting, the pilot, justifying scores, the weighting objection, what the pilot shows and the least certain criterion. Send your seminar's theories and an appraisal instrument follows at no cost.

Why report the reversal in DBA 805 Topic 2?

Showing that equal weights change the ranking reveals exactly what the weighting values. Hiding it would make every other judgment harder to trust.