| Course | DBA 805 Management Theory in a Global Economy |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Weak theory persistence discussion post |
| Length | About 420 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 805 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
A Vocabulary, Not a Finding: Why the Needs Hierarchy Outlives the Evidence Against It
Initial Post
My position is that the needs hierarchy persists because it gives managers a vocabulary, and a vocabulary is not the kind of thing evidence removes. I chose Maslow's hierarchy because everyone in this course has met the pyramid, usually before meeting any of the research on it.
The evidence is short to state. Maslow (1943) held that needs come in a sequence, with higher ones taking over as lower ones are met. Wahba and Bridwell (1976), reviewing the research that followed, found little support for a fixed ladder of needs in which meeting one rung brings the next into play. Later research on need satisfaction has not restored a strict ordering.
Three mechanisms explain why it survives anyway. First, the theory never fixed when a need counts as satisfied, so almost any pattern of behavior can be reconciled with it after the fact; a theory that cannot lose is hard to kill. Second, textbooks cite earlier textbooks, and the familiar triangle travels from one to the next. Bridgman et al. (2019) traced the pyramid itself to later management writers rather than to Maslow, who did not draw it, which shows how far the teaching version has drifted from its source. Third, the ordering reads as practical advice: pay people fairly and keep them safe before asking for creativity. Advice that sounds sensible survives even when the theory said to support it does not.
I would still teach the hierarchy, but as a case study in how frameworks outlive their evidence, set beside Wahba and Bridwell's review. My question for the class: what managerial idea that you use regularly would you be unable to defend with evidence if asked tomorrow?
Reply to Jordan
Jordan, you argue that the hierarchy deserves its place because managers find it useful, and that usefulness is its own test. I agree that a framework can help people notice needs they would otherwise overlook, such as security during a reorganization. But usefulness and truth come apart here in a way that matters. If a manager believes higher needs cannot motivate until lower ones are met, the hierarchy discourages offering meaningful work to people in insecure jobs, which the research does not support and many employees would reject. A tool that organizes attention is fine; a tool that predicts behavior wrongly and guides decisions by that prediction is not. Would you keep the vocabulary while dropping the claim of a fixed order?
References
Bridgman, T., Cummings, S., & Ballard, J. (2019). Who built Maslow's pyramid? A history of the creation of management studies' most famous symbol and its implications for management education. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 18(1), 81-98. https://doi.org/10.5465/amle.2017.0351
Maslow, A. H. (1943). A theory of human motivation. Psychological Review, 50(4), 370-396. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0054346
Wahba, M. A., & Bridwell, L. G. (1976). Maslow reconsidered: A review of research on the need hierarchy theory. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 15(2), 212-240. https://doi.org/10.1016/0030-5073(76)90038-6
What the DBA 805 Topic 5 instructions ask for
Topic 5 in DBA-805 asks doctoral students to explain in a discussion post why a weak theory persists. Strong posts state a position in the first lines, compress the evidence against the theory into a few cited sentences and set out specific survival mechanisms rather than general complaints. Students should say how the theory should be taught given its record, close by posing a question peers can test on their own practice and reply to a classmate by engaging the classmate's strongest point. Survival mechanisms should be specific enough that a classmate could check each one against the literature.
Inside the DBA 805 Topic 5 example
The post opens with its position in two sentences: the needs hierarchy persists because it supplies managers with a vocabulary, and a vocabulary is not the kind of thing evidence removes. Evidence follows. Wahba and Bridwell's review of the research found little support for the ordered hierarchy, and later work has not rescued the claim that needs activate in sequence. Three reasons for survival follow. The theory never fixed when a need counts as satisfied, so almost no pattern of behavior can contradict it. Textbooks cite earlier textbooks, and the pyramid itself, historians of the field have argued, was drawn by later management writers rather than by Maslow. And the ordering reads as advice to a manager deciding what to offer first. The post then defends teaching the hierarchy as a case study in how frameworks outlive evidence.
Reading the DBA 805 Topic 5 rubric
Faculty reward a post that explains survival rather than repeating criticism. An Excellent post cites Maslow's original paper and Wahba and Bridwell's review in a few sentences. Credit goes to three survival mechanisms, including the history of the pyramid from Bridgman and colleagues. The rubric values teaching the hierarchy as a case of a framework outliving evidence. Strong posts close by asking peers which of their own working ideas they could not defend with evidence. Top marks go to a reply that separates usefulness from predictive truth.
Common DBA 805 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them
A post that simply condemns the hierarchy as debunked has addressed whether it is weak, which the prompt takes as given, and left untouched why it persists. Replies listing reasons such as simplicity without a mechanism leave persistence as a mood rather than an explanation. Citing Wahba and Bridwell for more than their review supports, or inventing a figure from it, invites a classmate's correction and costs credibility with the instructor. Missing the unfalsifiable satisfaction threshold wastes the strongest link to the course's own criteria. Posts that recommend removing the theory from teaching rarely address where graduates will then encounter it. Ending the post by inviting classmates to name another weak theory produces a list, and doctoral threads reward the question that forces a position.
Get a DBA-805 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-805 Topic 5 discussion question as it appears in your classroom, the participation rubric and any theory the prompt names. A custom example is written to those requirements, with a position first, the evidence compressed, persistence explained by mechanism and the removal objection answered, and it returns in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More DBA 805 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 805 Topic 1: Theory-framework Boundary Essay
- DBA 805 Topic 2: Theory Appraisal Criteria Paper
- DBA 805 Topic 3: Construct Measurability Critique
- DBA 805 Topic 4: Theory Evidence Audit
- DBA 805 Topic 6: Theory Transfer Test
- DBA 805 Topic 7: Rival Explanation Test
- DBA 805 Topic 8: Theoretical Position Defense
- MKT 838 Topic 5: Contribution Claim Dq Post
- MKT 834 Topic 5: Test Abandonment Dq Post
- MKT 832 Topic 5: Click Meaning Dq Post
DBA 805 Topic 5 questions, answered
What did Wahba and Bridwell find about Maslow's hierarchy?
Mahmoud Wahba and Lawrence Bridwell reviewed the empirical research testing the need hierarchy and found that it gave the theory little consistent support, particularly for the claim that needs are arranged in a fixed order of prepotency. Their review is the standard citation for the evidence problem. The example cites it for that conclusion only and adds no figures from it, since a DQ post needs the finding rather than the details.
Did Maslow draw the pyramid?
Historians of management education have argued that he did not, and that the pyramid was introduced by later management writers who turned his ordering into a diagram. Maslow himself described the hierarchy as less rigid than the figure implies. The example uses that history as evidence for its persistence argument, since a shape added by textbooks shows how teaching can shape a theory more than its author did.
Why defend teaching a weak theory?
Because graduates will meet it anyway, in training materials, consultants' slides and colleagues' assumptions. A course that drops it leaves them unable to recognize its limits when it appears in a proposal. Taught as a framework with its evidence record, it becomes a case study in how management ideas outlive their support. The example grants the objection that this uses class time, and argues the time is well spent.
Where can I find a free DBA 805 Topic 5 sample paper?
The discussion post and reply are shown here complete: the position, the evidence, three survival mechanisms, how to teach it, a question for the class and the reply on usefulness. Paste your seminar's discussion prompt and a post follows free.
Why is the hierarchy hard to refute in DBA 805 Topic 5?
It never fixed when a need counts as satisfied, so almost any behavior can be reconciled with it after the fact.