| Course | MGT 641 Agile Project Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Adoption behavior audit |
| Length | About 1,140 words, 7 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 641 Topic 7
Every Ceremony Held, Few Conditions Met: A Behavior Audit of a Credit Union's First Year of Sprints on Its Member Lending App
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-641: Agile Project Management
Topic 7 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Every Ceremony Held, Few Conditions Met: A Behavior Audit of a Credit Union's First Year of Sprints on Its Member Lending App
What the Adoption Promised
Twelve months ago Sagebrook Community Credit Union moved its member lending app team to two-week sprints. The launch memo named two goals: release improvements to members faster, and respond to what members and lending staff ask for during the year rather than waiting for the next annual plan. This audit tests those two claims. It does not test whether the team follows Scrum's rules, because the answer to that question is already known and, as the next section explains, settles nothing.
The Ceremonies, Confirmed and Set Aside
Every planned sprint event took place for twelve months. Planning, daily meetings, reviews and retrospectives were all held on schedule, and attendance was good. That record proves the calendar was kept. It does not show whether anything about how Sagebrook builds and releases software changed. Conboy (2009) argues that agility should be judged by an organization's ability to create, embrace and learn from change, and by the economy and speed with which it does so, not by the presence of named practices. The audit follows that view and measures four behaviors instead.
Four Behaviors Measured
Table 1
Four Adoption Behaviors After Twelve Months, Illustrative
| Behavior | Measure | Source | Finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Release frequency | Production releases to members | Deployment records | Four, one per quarter |
| Scope flexibility | Mid-year requests absorbed into a sprint | Request log | 2 of 9 |
| Team stability | Developers replaced during the year | Vendor staffing reports | 5 of 7 |
| Team independence | Stories that waited on another group | Sprint records | About 38 percent |
Table 1 lists each behavior, the measure used, the source and the finding. The figures are illustrative.
Release Frequency
Members received new features four times in the year, the same as before the adoption. The cause is outside the team. Sagebrook's change advisory board approves production changes only in a quarterly window, so the work of six two-week sprints joins a queue and waits for that window. Short sprints have produced finished increments faster; they have not reached members faster. Forsgren et al. (2018) identify deployment frequency and lead time for changes as two of the four measures most closely linked to delivery performance, and on both Sagebrook is where it was a year ago.
Scope Flexibility
Lending staff made nine requests during the year that were not in the original plan, including a co-borrower field and a change to how declined applications are explained. Two were absorbed into a sprint. The other seven went through the vendor's change request process, which required a priced amendment and approval from the contracts office, and took an average of seven weeks to reach the backlog. The contract still fixes scope, so the team can respond to change only when the change is small enough to avoid the contract.
Team Stability
The vendor replaced five of its seven developers during the year, rotating them to other clients. Velocity never settled, ranging from 14 to 29 points a sprint, and each new developer spent most of a sprint learning the lending rules and the core system connections. Nothing in the contract or the adoption plan treated a stable team as a requirement, although the method depends on one. Teams that keep the same people build shared knowledge of the product and of each other, and that knowledge is what makes estimates reliable and handoffs short. Every rotation reset part of it. The two developers who stayed all year now hold most of the knowledge of the lending rules, which concentrates risk in two people the credit union does not employ.
Team Independence
About 38 percent of completed stories waited on another group before they could be finished, chiefly the core banking integration team and the compliance reviewers. The team cannot finish most member-facing work alone, so its sprint plans depend on queues it does not control.
The figure has not improved during the year. In the first quarter 41 percent of stories waited on another group, and in the last quarter 36 percent did, a difference small enough to come from the mix of work. Compliance waits did fall after the reviewers began attending refinement sessions every other sprint, which shows that the dependency can be shortened when someone decides to. Integration waits did not fall, because no comparable step was taken there. The team's members describe planning around these waits as the hardest part of their work, and several stories each quarter were started, blocked and then set aside, which also explains part of the gap between work begun and work finished.
Lead Time Traced
Lead time from an approved request to a member-facing release averaged 97 days. Three sample requests show where those days went. The co-borrower field spent 6 days in refinement, 10 in a sprint, 12 waiting on integration and 64 waiting for the release window, a total of 92 days. A change to the payment calendar spent 4 days in refinement, 10 in a sprint and 81 waiting for release. The declined-application explanation spent 49 days in the change request process, 10 in a sprint and 55 waiting for release. In each case the team's own work took 10 days, and most of the elapsed time passed in queues outside it.
The Pattern
Taken together, the findings describe what Theocharis et al. (2015) call Water-Scrum-Fall: agile practices inside the development team, surrounded by traditional upfront contracting at one end and traditional release control at the other. Their study found this hybrid common in practice. At Sagebrook it was not chosen deliberately; it is what remained when sprints were introduced and nothing around them changed.
The Too-Soon Defense
The project sponsor argues that a year is too short for behavior to change. The argument holds for some things. Retrospective habits and estimation consistency often improve with time, and a second year might show gains there. But the three largest findings will not move with time. A quarterly release window, a fixed-scope contract and a vendor free to rotate developers are policies, and each will produce the same result in year two unless someone changes it.
Recommendations
Each missing condition is assigned to the executive who controls it. The chief information officer should ask the change advisory board to approve low-risk releases monthly, with a lighter review for changes that do not touch core banking. The chief financial officer should renegotiate the vendor contract to price a team's capacity rather than a fixed scope, so lending requests enter the backlog directly. The vendor management director should add a clause holding named developers on the team for at least a year. The integration manager should give the lending app team access to make routine changes itself. The audit should be repeated in twelve months using the same four measures and the same lead-time trace.
References
Conboy, K. (2009). Agility from first principles: Reconstructing the concept of agility in information systems development. Information Systems Research, 20(3), 329-354. https://doi.org/10.1287/isre.1090.0236
Forsgren, N., Humble, J., & Kim, G. (2018). Accelerate: The science of lean software and DevOps: Building and scaling high performing technology organizations. IT Revolution Press.
Theocharis, G., Kuhrmann, M., Münch, J., & Diebold, P. (2015). Is Water-Scrum-Fall reality? On the use of agile and traditional development practices. In P. Abrahamsson, L. Corral, M. Oivo, & B. Russo (Eds.), Product-focused software process improvement (pp. 149-166). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-26844-6_11
What the MGT 641 Topic 7 instructions ask for
Topic 7 in MGT-641 asks whether an agile adoption has actually changed how an organization delivers. Counting meetings held or rising velocity does not answer that question. A paper meets the brief when it starts from the adoption's stated goals, chooses behavioral measures such as release frequency, scope flexibility, team stability and independence, and finds evidence for each in records rather than opinions. Graduate students should draw on research about agility and delivery performance, trace lead time through real requests to show where time is lost, and name the pattern the findings describe. The audit should address the argument that it is too soon to judge and end with recommendations tied to the executives who control each missing condition.
How this MGT 641 Topic 7 example is built
The finished audit concedes the calendar at once: every planned sprint event took place for twelve months. It then measures four behaviors, numbers illustrative. Releases to members still happen quarterly, because the change advisory board approves production changes only in a quarterly window, so two-week sprints feed a three-month queue. Of nine mid-year requests from lending staff, two were absorbed into a sprint and seven went through the vendor's change request process, which shows scope still governed by contract. The vendor replaced five of the seven developers during the year, so velocity never settled. About 38 percent of completed stories waited on another group, chiefly the core banking integration team. Lead time from an approved request to a member-facing release averaged 97 days. Its conclusion is that the practices were installed and the conditions were not.
MGT 641 Topic 7 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Graders award an Excellent audit for measuring outcomes and conditions rather than ritual. The rubric rewards papers that concede the ceremonies briefly and then set them aside, choose measures with clear sources, and connect each finding to its cause, such as the quarterly release window that cancels the benefit of short sprints. Credit goes to tracing several requests end to end so the lead-time figure has concrete cases. Strong papers treat developer turnover as a condition the method depends on and recognize the water-scrum-fall pattern. The highest band separates what time might improve from what only a policy change will fix, and assigns one recommendation per missing condition to the executive who owns it.
MGT 641 Topic 7 help before you submit
An adoption audit that reports full attendance and a satisfied team has measured the ritual this topic warns against. Papers counting velocity growth as evidence of success confuse a team's own unit with a result members can feel, and velocity can rise while nothing reaches production faster. Missing the release window is the costliest oversight in this case, since it cancels the benefit of short sprints however well they run. Treating developer turnover as a staffing footnote overlooks a condition the method depends on. Blaming the team for slow lead time ignores that most of the 97 days pass in queues it does not control. The too-soon defense deserves a direct answer as well, one that separates what a second year might improve from what only a changed contract, board or staffing policy could.
Get an MGT-641 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-641 Topic 7 instructions, the rubric for it and any adoption goals, delivery data or case the assignment supplies. A custom example is written to those requirements, with ceremonies set aside, four behaviors measured from records, lead time traced end to end and each missing condition assigned an owner, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 641 papers and MBA samples
- MGT 641 Topic 1: Agile Manifesto Assumptions Paper
- MGT 641 Topic 2: Scrum Event Purpose Audit
- MGT 641 Topic 3: Backlog Ordering Rationale
- MGT 641 Topic 4: Story Point Estimation Memo
- MGT 641 Topic 5: Proxy Product Owner Dq Post
- MGT 641 Topic 6: Scaling Framework Critique
- MGT 641 Topic 8: Hybrid Delivery Defense
- MGT 655 Topic 7: Schedule Slack Analysis
- MGT 640 Topic 7: Benefits Realization Review
- MGT 660 Topic 7: Structure and Governance Fit
- MGT 605 Topic 7: Team and Change Analysis
MGT 641 Topic 7 questions, answered
What measures show whether an agile adoption is working?
Measures of outcome and flow rather than activity. Forsgren, Humble and Kim's research on software delivery, reported in Accelerate, uses deployment frequency, lead time for changes, change failure rate and time to restore service. The example adds two condition checks the course emphasizes: whether scope actually changed in response to learning, and whether the team stayed together long enough to become predictable.
Why not measure velocity?
Velocity helps a team forecast its own work, but it is a relative unit the team controls, and it can rise through re-estimation without anything changing for users. Used as an adoption measure, it invites inflation. The example uses it only to show instability after developer turnover, and relies on release and lead time records for the judgment about whether members are served faster.
Is a year long enough to judge an adoption?
Long enough to judge conditions, if not every outcome. Some practices do improve with time, such as retrospective follow-through or estimation consistency. A quarterly release window, a fixed-scope contract and a rotating vendor team will not improve by waiting, because nothing in the sprint cycle can change them. The example separates the two groups and asks the credit union to act on the second.
Where can I find a free MGT 641 Topic 7 sample paper?
The full first-year adoption audit is on this page: goals, the ceremonies set aside, the four behaviors, the 97-day lead-time trace, the pattern, the too-soon defense and the recommendations. Tell us about your organization's adoption and a free audit can be written from its records.
Why did releases stay quarterly in MGT 641 Topic 7?
The change advisory board approves production changes only in a quarterly window, so increments from six two-week sprints wait together for release. The team finished work faster, but members did not receive it any sooner.