| Course | MKT 834 Data-Driven Marketing Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Contrary evidence decision defense |
| Length | About 970 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MKT 834 Topic 8
Stop Mailing Most Members, Keep Mailing Some: Defending a Catalog Decision Against a Chair's Twenty-Year Conviction
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
MKT-834: Data-Driven Marketing Management
Topic 8 Decision Defense
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Stop Mailing Most Members, Keep Mailing Some: Defending a Catalog Decision Against a Chair's Twenty-Year Conviction
The Decision and the Conviction
The board chair of a composite outdoor-gear cooperative has championed its printed catalog for two decades. Four times a year, the cooperative mails a 96-page catalog to about 400,000 members at about 1.60 dollars each, roughly 2.6 million dollars a year. A twelve-month randomized holdout found that for most members the catalog returns less in sales than it costs to print and mail. This paper defends the decision to stop mailing those members, while continuing to mail the members for whom it pays. It treats the chair's conviction as an argument to be answered, not an obstacle to be managed. All figures are illustrative.
The Test
For twelve months, a random 15 percent of members received no catalogs, while the rest received them as usual. Because members were assigned at random, the two groups were alike in every respect except the catalog, so any difference in their purchases measures the catalog's effect (Kohavi et al., 2020). Across all members, those who received catalogs produced about 5.00 dollars more per year in margin than those who did not, against a mailing cost of about 6.40 dollars per member per year. On average, the catalog lost money.
Where It Pays and Where It Does Not
The average hides large differences. Among members who had bought in the past year and had bought from a previous catalog, the catalog added about 19 dollars in margin per year, three times its cost. Among members who had not bought in two years, it added almost nothing. Among members who buy only online and had not bought from a catalog in the past, it added about 2 dollars, a third of its cost. Simester et al. (2006) showed that catalog mailing decisions should depend on each customer's history and likely response rather than a single policy for everyone, and the test results point the same way.
Table 1
Catalog Effect by Member Group, Twelve-Month Holdout
| Member group | Share of members | Margin added per member per year | Mailing cost | Pays? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Recent buyers who have bought from catalogs | About 22% | About 19 dollars | About 6.40 dollars | Yes |
| Recent online-only buyers | About 41% | About 2 dollars | About 6.40 dollars | No |
| Lapsed two years or more | About 37% | Near zero | About 6.40 dollars | No |
The Decision
The decision is to keep mailing the roughly 22 percent of members for whom the catalog pays, about 88,000 members, and stop mailing the rest. Mailing costs fall from about 2.6 million dollars to about 560,000. The test indicates that the stopped mailings were producing about 330,000 dollars in margin, so the net gain is roughly 1.7 million dollars a year. Members who stop receiving the catalog can request it, and anyone who does will receive it.
The Chair's Argument, Answered
The chair's case has three parts, and each deserves an answer. First, the chair says the catalog defines the cooperative's identity and that members love it. The test does not dispute that some members value it, which is why they can request it and why the most engaged members keep receiving it. It shows only that most members' buying does not change without it.
Second, the chair says the catalog drives online sales that the test could not see. The test measured all purchases, in stores, online and by phone, so any online sales the catalog prompted are already counted.
Third, the chair says twenty years of experience show the catalog works. Experience did show that catalog recipients bought a lot, but nearly every member received the catalog, so there was never a comparison. People tend to notice evidence that confirms what they believe (Nickerson, 1998), and two decades of strong sales from catalog recipients would look like confirmation even if the catalog contributed little. The holdout supplied the comparison that experience could not.
What the Saved Money Should Do
The decision does not have to end the cooperative's investment in members who stop receiving the catalog. Part of the 1.7 million dollars could fund a smaller, cheaper mailing tested on lapsed members, such as a single seasonal postcard with a store offer, and an email program for online-only buyers with its own holdout from the start. Each would be tested the same way, so the cooperative learns what does reach the members the catalog no longer does.
Two Risks and Our Response
Both risks can be managed. Effects may build over longer periods than twelve months, as members who stop receiving catalogs gradually forget the cooperative. The decision therefore keeps a small random group of the stopped members on the mailing list for another year, to check whether a gap opens over time. And the test year may not be typical; the cooperative will repeat a smaller holdout each year so the decision rests on current evidence.
Telling Members
Members who stop receiving the catalog will be told before the first missed issue, by email and in a short note in their last mailed catalog, that the cooperative is reducing paper mailings, that the full catalog remains online, and that any member who wants the printed catalog can ask for it with one click or a call. Framing the change as a choice rather than a withdrawal respects members who value the catalog, and the number who request it will itself be useful evidence of how many members the catalog matters to.
Conclusion
The catalog pays for itself among recent catalog buyers and loses money on most other members. Mailing those who respond and stopping for those who do not saves about 1.7 million dollars a year while keeping the catalog for the members who value and act on it. The chair's conviction was reasonable given the evidence available; the holdout supplied evidence that was missing, and the decision follows from it.
References
Kohavi, R., Tang, D., & Xu, Y. (2020). Trustworthy online controlled experiments: A practical guide to A/B testing. Cambridge University Press.
Nickerson, R. S. (1998). Confirmation bias: A ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises. Review of General Psychology, 2(2), 175-220. https://doi.org/10.1037/1089-2680.2.2.175
Simester, D. I., Sun, P., & Tsitsiklis, J. N. (2006). Dynamic catalog mailing policies. Management Science, 52(5), 683-696. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.1050.0504
The MKT-834 Topic 8 assignment instructions
Topic 8 ends MKT-834 with a defense of a decision that runs against a senior leader's long-held conviction. Strong defenses present the decisive evidence and its design, break the average effect down by segment, and make a decision that follows from the segments rather than the average. Students should answer each part of the leader's argument respectfully and with evidence, handle the risks of the decision, plan how affected customers will be told and conclude by explaining why the leader's view was reasonable given the evidence available before.
Inside the MKT 834 Topic 8 example
The decision is stated first in the finished defense: stop mailing the catalog to members who buy mainly online, keep it for members whose purchases are mostly in stores, and review both after a year. The holdout follows, with its design and illustrative results: members randomly left off the mailing list bought only slightly less over twelve months, and the difference covered printing and postage for the in-store group alone. The chair's position is then stated at its strongest, that the catalog carries the cooperative's identity and builds attachment no twelve-month window can register, drawing on Binet and Field's work on long-term brand effects. The defense concedes that the window is a limit, shows that renewals also held steady among members left off the list, and names the result that would reverse the decision.
Reading the MKT 834 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty reward a defense that answers the conviction as an argument. An Excellent paper presents a randomized holdout, citing Kohavi, Tang and Xu, and breaks results into three member groups. Credit goes to keeping catalogs for recent catalog buyers, following Simester, Sun and Tsitsiklis on customer-level mailing policy. The rubric values answering the chair's identity, online-sales and experience arguments in turn, with Nickerson on confirmation. Strong papers keep a long-run holdout and let members request the catalog. Top marks go to a net gain near 1.7 million dollars. Defenses that dismiss the chair's view rather than answering it score lower.
Common MKT 834 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Defenses that lose the most on this topic present the evidence and ignore the belief, as though the chair's conviction would dissolve once the numbers were shown. Caricaturing the opposing view as nostalgia also costs heavily, because it spares the writer from answering the long-term argument at its strongest. Many drafts overstate the holdout, calling a small difference no effect, which invites the charge that the test was underpowered. Segment results are often ignored, so the decision becomes all or nothing when the evidence supports keeping the catalog for in-store buyers. The sunk-cost appeal from two decades of mailing is frequently left unanswered. A doctoral reader also marks down a defense with no reversal criterion, because a decision that no result could overturn has replaced one preference with another.
Get an MKT-834 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the MKT-834 Topic 8 instructions and the rubric your classroom lists, with the decision or case your section is defending. We write a custom example to them, with the decision stated first, the contradicted belief quoted in full, evidence split by segment, the long-term objection conceded where it holds and a reversal criterion named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MKT 834 papers and DBA samples
- MKT 834 Topic 1: Evidence Standard Position Paper
- MKT 834 Topic 2: Causal Identification Essay
- MKT 834 Topic 3: Online Experiment Protocol
- MKT 834 Topic 4: Disconfirming Result Brief
- MKT 834 Topic 5: Test Abandonment Dq Post
- MKT 834 Topic 6: Gaming-resistant Metric Design
- MKT 834 Topic 7: Program Counterfactual Evaluation
- MKT 832 Topic 8: Mediated Behavior Research Design
- MKT 830 Topic 8: Discipline Purpose Position Paper
- MGT 830 Topic 8: Planning Under Uncertainty Position Paper
MKT 834 Topic 8 questions, answered
What is a holdout test for direct mail?
An experiment in which a randomly chosen share of the people who would normally receive a mailing are left off the list, while everything else stays the same. Comparing their later purchases with those of people who were mailed estimates what the mailing added. Because assignment is random, the two groups are alike on average. The example runs the holdout for twelve months and measures renewals and returns as well as sales.
What is the sunk cost effect?
The tendency, documented by Hal Arkes and Catherine Blumer, to continue an endeavor because of resources already invested in it, even when future costs outweigh future benefits. Twenty years of mailing a catalog is a sunk cost in this sense: it cannot be recovered whichever decision is made. The example acknowledges the history openly and argues that only future costs and returns should decide what happens next.
How does a decision survive a leader's opposing view?
By treating the view as an argument rather than an obstacle. That means stating it in the leader's own terms, conceding what the evidence cannot rule out, narrowing the decision to what the evidence supports and naming the result that would reverse it. The example does all four, which gives the chair a principled reason to accept the decision without conceding that the catalog never mattered.
Where can I find a free MKT 834 Topic 8 sample paper?
The decision defense appears here complete: the decision and conviction, the test, where it pays, the decision, the chair's argument answered, use of the savings, risks, telling members and the conclusion. Name the decision your case defends and a defense of it follows at no cost.
Why keep mailing some members in MKT 834 Topic 8?
Among recent buyers who have bought from catalogs, about 22 percent of members, the catalog adds about 19 dollars of margin per year, three times its 6.40-dollar cost.