| Course | BUS 332 Customer Engagement |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Service failure analysis |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS 332 Topic 4
Which Service Failures Cost Contracts? Late Arrivals Are Forgiven, Broken Promises and Blame Are Not, and the Improvement Effort Is Aimed at the Wrong Corner
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
BUS-332: Customer Engagement
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Which Service Failures Cost Contracts? Late Arrivals Are Forgiven, Broken Promises and Blame Are Not, and the Improvement Effort Is Aimed at the Wrong Corner
Starting From Operations, Not Complaints
Comfort Pro Heating and Cooling, a composite service firm, holds about 6,000 annual service contracts and makes about 12,000 service calls a year. Its management has been tracking complaints to decide where to improve. Complaints are a poor guide, because many customers who experience a failure never report it; they simply decline to renew. This analysis therefore classifies failures from the firm's own operational records: the dispatch log, which shows arrival times against the promised window; work orders, which show repeat visits and parts orders; and technician notes, which record what the customer was told. Each failure is then matched to whether the customer renewed the contract the following year.
The Failure Types
Four types of failure appear often enough to analyze. Late arrival, beyond the promised two-hour window. A second visit for the same fault, because the first repair did not hold or the technician lacked a part. A parts date given to the customer and then missed, sometimes more than once. And a technician telling the customer the fault was the customer's doing, such as blocked vents or a tripped switch, when the firm later found and fixed a defect under warranty.
Failure Against Renewal
Among contract customers who experienced none of these failures in the year, 88 percent renewed. The table sets each failure type against that baseline.
Table 1
Service Failures and Contract Renewal
| Failure type | Share of jobs | Customers affected | Renewal rate | Renewal gap against 88% baseline | Contracts lost a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Late arrival beyond the window | 14% | 1,680 | 84% | 4 points | 67 |
| Second visit for the same fault | 11% | 1,320 | 80% | 8 points | 106 |
| Parts date given and then missed | 4% | 480 | 52% | 36 points | 173 |
| Technician blamed the customer for a fault later fixed under warranty | 1.5% | 180 | 41% | 47 points | 85 |
The Central Finding
Late arrivals and second visits are common and mostly forgiven. Customers affected by a late arrival renewed at 84 percent, only four points below the baseline; a second visit cost eight points. Customers appear to accept that service schedules slip and that some repairs need a return trip, provided the problem is eventually fixed.
Missed parts dates and blame are rarer and much more damaging. Only 4 percent of jobs involved a missed parts date, but those customers renewed at just 52 percent. The rarest failure, blaming the customer for a fault the firm later fixed, affected 1.5 percent of jobs, and fewer than half of those customers renewed. These failures break a promise or question the customer's competence, and research on switching behavior finds that failed service encounters involving unhelpful or rude employee responses are among the strongest reasons customers leave (Keaveney, 1995).
Why the Complaint Inbox Missed It
Comparing the operational records with the complaint log shows why management's picture was incomplete. About one in five late arrivals produced a complaint, usually a same-day call asking where the technician was. Fewer than one in twenty missed parts dates did, and almost none of the blame incidents. Customers who feel they have been misled or accused often do not bother to complain; they conclude the firm is not worth the effort and quietly leave at renewal. A complaint-based view therefore overweights the failures customers find annoying and underweights those they find unforgivable.
The Frequency and Severity Grid
Placing the failure types on a grid of frequency against severity makes the pattern visible. Late arrivals sit in the frequent, low-severity corner. Second visits are frequent and moderately severe. Missed parts dates and blame sit in the rare, high-severity corner. Multiplying the share of jobs by the renewal gap shows each type's total cost in lost contracts: missed parts dates cost about 173 contracts a year, more than any other failure, and blame costs about 85, despite affecting only 180 customers.
The Effort Is Aimed at the Wrong Corner
Comfort Pro's current improvement program focuses almost entirely on punctuality: GPS tracking of vans, tighter scheduling and a target of 95 percent on-time arrivals. That is the frequent, low-severity corner, where improvement would save at most about 67 contracts. The high-severity corner receives no attention, because those failures rarely generate complaints and do not appear in the punctuality measures. Research on complaint handling shows that how the firm treats customers after something goes wrong, not just the failure itself, shapes whether they stay (Tax et al., 1998).
What to Change
Three changes follow. First, stop giving customers parts dates that depend on suppliers the firm does not control; give a date only once the part is confirmed shipped, and call the customer the day before. Second, train technicians never to attribute a fault to the customer until it has been confirmed, and review every warranty repair where the customer was earlier told the fault was theirs. Third, when either failure occurs, make a recovery call from a supervisor with an apology and a service credit; recovery efforts that address the customer's sense of fair treatment, not only the outcome, have the strongest effect on satisfaction after a failure (Smith et al., 1999). The punctuality program can continue, but its budget should not crowd out these changes, which address the failures that actually cost contracts.
Measuring Progress
Progress should be measured in the same terms as the analysis. Each quarter, the firm should count missed parts dates and blame incidents from the work orders and technician notes, and track renewal rates among customers who experienced each failure type. The target is not zero failures, which is unrealistic, but a narrowing of the renewal gap for the severe types, from 36 and 47 points toward the four to eight points of the forgiven failures. A narrowing gap would show that recovery calls are working even where failures still occur. Punctuality should remain on the dashboard, but as one measure among several rather than the headline.
References
Keaveney, S. M. (1995). Customer switching behavior in service industries: An exploratory study. Journal of Marketing, 59(2), 71-82. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224299505900206
Smith, A. K., Bolton, R. N., & Wagner, J. (1999). A model of customer satisfaction with service encounters involving failure and recovery. Journal of Marketing Research, 36(3), 356-372. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224379903600305
Tax, S. S., Brown, S. W., & Chandrashekaran, M. (1998). Customer evaluations of service complaint experiences: Implications for relationship marketing. Journal of Marketing, 62(2), 60-76. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224299806200205
BUS 332 Topic 4 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 4 instructions in BUS-332 ask students to analyze service failures and their effect on customer retention. Weak submissions rely on complaint logs. The assignment rewards analyses that classify failures from operational records, since many customers never complain, and match each failure type to a retention outcome against a baseline. Students should build a frequency and severity grid, estimate the retention cost of each failure type, compare the firm's current improvement effort with where the losses actually are, explain why complaints missed the pattern and recommend changes with a way of measuring progress.
How this BUS 332 Topic 4 example is built
The finished analysis classifies failures from the firm's operational records, not from its complaint inbox, since many customers who experience a failure never report it. Each failure type is then matched against whether the customer renewed their service contract. The pattern that emerges is the central finding: late arrivals and a second visit for the same fault are common and mostly forgiven, while a parts date that turns out to be false, or a technician blaming the customer for a fault the firm later fixed under warranty, is rarer and followed by departure far more often. The example builds a frequency and severity grid from this evidence and argues that the firm's improvement effort is aimed at the wrong corner of it.
Where the marks sit in the BUS 332 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty grading the service failure analysis reward evidence from operations rather than complaints. Excellent analyses set each failure type against a renewal baseline and convert the gap into contracts lost. Credit goes to showing that rare failures that break promises or blame customers cost more than frequent ones. The rubric values a frequency and severity grid used to judge where improvement effort is going. The highest level explains why the complaint inbox understated the severe failures and proposes recovery steps tied to fair treatment. Analyses that rank failures by complaint volume, or that stop at frequency without severity, usually land in a middle band.
BUS 332 Topic 4 help: mistakes that cost marks
Ranking failures by how often customers complain about them sends the analysis in the wrong direction, because complaint volume tracks irritation and the relationship-ending events are often quieter. Relying on the complaint log at all misses customers who left without saying anything, and the topic expects that gap to be recognized. An analysis with no link between failure and later behavior can only guess which failures matter. Comparing renewal after a failure without a baseline for customers who had none makes every rate look alarming or reassuring by accident. Treating association as proof that one failure caused departure overstates the evidence, and saying so strengthens the paper. Recommendations aimed at the most frequent irritation spend effort where customers were already forgiving.
Get a BUS-332 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the BUS-332 Topic 4 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the case records or scenario your section uses. We write a custom example to those instructions and that rubric, with failures drawn from operational records, each type linked to later renewal, frequency separated from severity and effort redirected accordingly, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More BUS 332 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- BUS 332 Topic 1: Retention Economics Comparison
- BUS 332 Topic 2: Customer Lifetime Value Calculation
- BUS 332 Topic 3: Value Segmentation Analysis
- BUS 332 Topic 5: Loyalty Program Dq Response
- BUS 332 Topic 6: Service Recovery Evaluation
- BUS 332 Topic 7: Engagement Measurement Proposal
- BUS 332 Topic 8: Targeted Retention Plan
- BUS 340 Topic 4: Vicarious Liability Analysis
- BUS 317 Topic 4: Break-even Sensitivity Analysis
- BUS 352 Topic 4: Interval Estimate Memo
- MGT 475 Topic 4: Algorithmic Screening Audit
BUS 332 Topic 4 questions, answered
Why are complaint counts a poor guide to which failures matter?
Because many dissatisfied customers never complain; they simply do not come back. Complaints overrepresent the customers still invested enough to argue and the failures that are annoying in the moment. The failures that end relationships often involve a loss of trust that customers see no point in reporting. Operational records and later buying behavior capture both groups, which a complaint log cannot.
What makes a service failure relationship-ending?
In the example's evidence, the failures followed by departure are the ones that make the customer doubt the firm's honesty or competence, not merely its punctuality. Being given a false date, being blamed for the firm's own error or having to prove a problem repeatedly tells the customer something about every future visit. A late technician tells them only about one afternoon.
Can the analysis prove that a failure caused a customer to leave?
Not on its own. Customers who experience a particular failure may differ from others in ways that also affect renewal, such as older appliances or more frequent service needs. The example reports association honestly, compares against customers without failures and checks whether the pattern holds across appliance types. That falls short of proof and is still far stronger than inferring severity from complaints.
Where can I find a free BUS 332 Topic 4 sample paper?
You can read the whole analysis here: starting from operations, the failure types, failure against renewal, the central finding, why complaints missed it, the grid, where the effort is aimed, what to change and measuring progress. Share your service records for a free worked analysis.
Which failure costs the most contracts in BUS 332 Topic 4?
Missed parts dates, about 173 contracts a year, because customers affected renew at 52 percent against an 88 percent baseline.