| Course | BUS 332 Customer Engagement |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Loyalty program discussion response |
| Length | About 410 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS 332 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Most Grocery Points Programs Reward Loyalty That Already Existed: Selection, Habit and the Narrow Case Where Rewards Do Change Behavior
Initial Post
My position: a grocery points program mostly rewards shoppers who were already loyal, and the spending gap between members and non-members greatly overstates what the program achieves.
The core problem is selection. The shoppers most likely to join a points scheme are the ones who already shop at the store most often, because they have the most to gain. So when the grocer reports that members spend twice as much as non-members, much of that gap existed before the program began. Comparing members with non-members measures who joined, not what joining changed. A fair test would compare the same shoppers' spending before and after they joined, against similar shoppers who did not join, and the difference is usually far smaller.
It also helps to separate repeat buying from real preference. A shopper can return week after week out of habit or convenience, because the store is on the way home, with no attachment to the brand at all. That shopper looks loyal in the data, collects points and would leave the moment a closer store opened. The points did not create the behavior and would not prevent the departure.
Dowling and Uncles made this argument in a well-known critique, questioning whether loyalty programs change behavior in competitive markets, since rivals copy them quickly and the programs end up as a cost of doing business rather than an advantage (Dowling & Uncles, 1997).
Where I would concede: programs can work for split shoppers, people who divide their spending between two nearby grocers. For them, a reward can tip which store gets the weekly shop. A program designed around that group, with offers aimed at categories they currently buy elsewhere, can change behavior. The test is whether the grocer can show added spending from those shoppers, not higher spending among members in general (Kotler & Keller, 2016).
Reply to Tasha
Tasha, you cited the grocer's finding that members spend $140 a week against $70 for non-members as proof the program works. The figure is real, but it compares different people. Heavy shoppers join because they earn the most points; the $70 shoppers include many who only stop in for milk. Do you know what members spent in the months before they joined? If it was close to $140, the program is paying for spending it did not create.
References
Dowling, G. R., & Uncles, M. (1997). Do customer loyalty programs really work? Sloan Management Review, 38(4), 71-82.
Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2016). Marketing management (15th ed.). Pearson.
The BUS-332 Topic 5 assignment instructions
BUS-332 Topic 5 asks students to evaluate whether loyalty programs create loyalty. Many posts accept member spending figures as evidence that a program works, without asking who chose to join. Well-graded posts state a clear position, explain the selection problem in comparing members with non-members, and describe what a fair test would compare instead. Students should distinguish repeat buying from genuine preference, draw on the published critique of loyalty programs, concede the conditions under which programs can change behavior, such as shoppers who split spending between stores, and reply to a classmate's evidence by asking the question that would test it.
How the BUS-332 Topic 5 example is put together
The finished response takes a clear position in its first sentence and then qualifies it with evidence. The core argument is selection: the shoppers who join a grocery points scheme are largely the ones who already bought there most, so comparing members with non-members shows a spending gap the program did not create. The post separates repeat buying from genuine preference, noting that a shopper can return out of habit or convenience with no attachment at all. It draws on Dowling and Uncles, whose well-known critique questioned whether such programs change behavior in competitive markets, and it concedes where programs can work, for example where a reward changes which store a split shopper chooses. A reply to a classmate who cited member spending follows.
BUS 332 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like
GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards a position stated first and then qualified with evidence. Excellent posts explain selection clearly enough that a classmate could spot it in other data. Credit goes to distinguishing habit and convenience from attachment. The rubric values accurate use of Dowling and Uncles and a fair concession about split shoppers. The strongest replies ask what members spent before joining rather than disputing the spending figure itself. Posts that treat the member spending gap as proof of the program's effect, or that dismiss every program without a concession, usually land in a middle band.
Common BUS 332 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Posts that accept the operator's own member figures as proof of success lose credit here, since those figures compare self-selected heavy buyers with everyone else. A flat yes or no also scores poorly, because the defensible answer depends on the market, the design of the scheme and which kind of loyalty is meant. Using loyalty to mean repeat purchase in one paragraph and emotional attachment in the next leaves the argument unable to conclude anything. Claims about program effects offered without any evidence standard are opinion, however confident. Ignoring the discount cost of rewarding customers who would have bought anyway overlooks what the scheme spends. Replies that simply agree with a classmate, or restate the initial post, contribute little to the discussion.
Get a BUS-332 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the BUS-332 Topic 5 discussion question and the rubric your classroom provides, with any program or company your section named. We write a custom example to those instructions and that rubric, with loyalty defined in both senses, selection explained, a fair test described and a classmate reply that engages the evidence, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More BUS 332 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- BUS 332 Topic 1: Retention Economics Comparison
- BUS 332 Topic 2: Customer Lifetime Value Calculation
- BUS 332 Topic 3: Value Segmentation Analysis
- BUS 332 Topic 4: Service Failure Analysis
- BUS 332 Topic 6: Service Recovery Evaluation
- BUS 332 Topic 7: Engagement Measurement Proposal
- BUS 332 Topic 8: Targeted Retention Plan
- BUS 340 Topic 5: Law and Ethics Divergence Dq
- BUS 317 Topic 5: Relevant Cost Dq Post
- BUS 352 Topic 5: P Value Dq Response
- MGT 475 Topic 5: Recommendation Ownership Dq Post
BUS 332 Topic 5 questions, answered
How does behavioral loyalty differ from attitudinal loyalty?
Behavioral loyalty is what customers do: returning, buying again, concentrating their spending with one seller. Attitudinal loyalty is how they feel: preference, trust, willingness to recommend. The two often travel together and need not. A shopper can return constantly because the store is closest while feeling nothing for it, and that shopper leaves the moment a closer option opens.
Can a loyalty program ever change behavior?
Yes, under particular conditions. Where customers split their purchases between competitors, a reward can tip the marginal choice toward one of them. Tiered status can hold frequent travelers who sit close to a threshold. Rewards tied to a new behavior, such as trying another department, can shift habits at the edges. What programs rarely do is convert indifferent customers into committed ones.
What would a fair test of a points program compare?
The behavior of new members before and after they joined, set against a matched group of similar shoppers who did not join over the same period. Some firms go further and withhold the program from a random set of customers. Either design separates what the scheme caused from what members would have done anyway, which a simple member versus non-member comparison cannot.
Where can I find a free BUS 332 Topic 5 sample paper?
The discussion post and a reply to Tasha are both on this page, covering the position, selection, habit versus preference, the published critique and the case where programs work. Pass along the prompt from your course and we will prepare a free sample post on it.
Why is the member spending gap misleading in BUS 332 Topic 5?
Heavy shoppers join because they earn the most points, so much of the gap existed before the program and was not created by it.