| Course | BUS 340 Ethical and Legal Issues in Business |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Law and ethics divergence discussion |
| Length | About 430 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS 340 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Lawful but Not Right: Why a Hardware Chain's 40 Percent Generator Markup After a Storm Fails a Duty-Based Test, and What Would Change My Mind
Initial Post
The law is quick to settle. After the hurricane, the chain raised generator prices from $700 to $980 in its coastal stores. The state in this case has no price-gouging statute, the new prices were posted openly on the shelves and online, and every sale was a voluntary contract at the posted price. Nothing in contract or consumer protection law made the increase unlawful.
The ethical question is separate, and I will use a duty-based framework to answer it. Kant's formula of humanity holds that we must treat people never merely as a means to our own ends, but always also as ends in themselves (Kant, 1785/1998). A price raised specifically because customers are desperate, with no change in what it costs the chain to supply the generator, uses the customer's emergency as the source of the chain's gain. The customer is treated as a means: their need is the lever. That is a strong reason to think the markup was wrong, even though it was lawful.
The strongest reply deserves a fair statement. Higher prices ration scarce units toward those who need them most rather than those who arrive first, discourage hoarding and draw more supply into the storm area, because out-of-state sellers will truck in generators when prices are high. On this view, laws and norms against price gouging leave people worse off, since they create shortages (Zwolinski, 2008). That argument is serious, and it is strongest where higher prices actually bring more supply.
I still take the position that the markup was wrong, because the chain's increase did none of that work. It raised prices on stock already in its stores, with no added cost and no evidence it brought in extra supply; it simply captured the difference. What would change my mind is evidence that the chain used the higher margin to fund emergency shipments that otherwise would not have arrived, and that the increase covered little more than that added cost. Then the price would be serving customers, not using them.
Reply to Marcus
Marcus, you argued that because the prices were legal and posted, customers consented and no one was wronged. Consent matters, and the chain did not deceive anyone. But consent given under a threat of losing power to a medical device or a freezer full of food is thin consent. Would you say the same if the chain had raised prices on insulin coolers rather than generators?
References
Kant, I. (1998). Groundwork of the metaphysics of morals (M. Gregor, Trans.). Cambridge University Press. (Original work published 1785)
Zwolinski, M. (2008). The ethics of price gouging. Business Ethics Quarterly, 18(3), 347-378. https://doi.org/10.5840/beq200818327
BUS 340 Topic 5 instructions, in plain terms
BUS-340 Topic 5 asks students to discuss a case where law and ethics diverge. Many posts blur the two. Posts that do well settle the legal question first and briefly, then open the ethical argument in a separate paragraph with its framework named. Students should apply the framework to the facts, state the strongest opposing argument fairly, take a position anyway, say what fact would change it, cite sources accurately and answer a classmate by putting that classmate's reasoning to a harder variation of the case.
How the BUS-340 Topic 5 example is put together
The finished post is a single substantial contribution, built to be read once and judged whole. Its first paragraph settles the law quickly: the composite state has no price-gouging statute, the chain posted its prices openly, and nothing in contract or consumer protection law made the increase unlawful. The ethical argument then begins as a separate paragraph with its own framework named. The post uses a duty-based view to argue that pricing to a customer's desperation treats that customer merely as a means, and it sets against that the strongest reply, that higher prices ration scarce units and draw supply toward the storm. It takes a position anyway, and says what fact would change it. Two sources are cited, and a short reply to a classmate is included.
Where the marks sit in the BUS 340 Topic 5 rubric
GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards law and ethics kept apart and both answered. Excellent posts name the framework and apply it to specific facts rather than general principles. Credit goes to stating the rationing and supply argument at full strength. The rubric values a position that survives the reply and a stated fact that would change it. The strongest replies test a classmate's consent argument against a harder case. Posts that call the increase wrong because it seems unfair, with no framework, or that treat legality as settling ethics, usually land in a middle band.
BUS 340 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Where this discussion goes wrong, it nearly always goes wrong at the seam between the two analyses. A post that establishes the increase was legal and then treats the question as closed has let the statute answer a question it never addressed, the collapse this whole course is organized against. The opposite slip also costs marks: arguing from fairness without first checking whether a statute or a contract term governed. Frameworks listed by name and never applied read as vocabulary rather than reasoning. A counterargument chosen because it is easy to beat leaves the position untested, and faculty notice when the rationing argument, the obvious one here, is missing. Posts that arrive late or run as a string of short fragments also tend to lose participation credit in sections that grade it.
Get a BUS-340 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the BUS-340 Topic 5 discussion question exactly as it appears in your classroom, with the rubric and any case your section named. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the law settled first, the ethical argument made separately and the strongest objection answered, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More BUS 340 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- BUS 340 Topic 1: Legal Exposure Map
- BUS 340 Topic 2: Contract Formation Analysis
- BUS 340 Topic 3: Employment Exposure Memo
- BUS 340 Topic 4: Vicarious Liability Analysis
- BUS 340 Topic 6: Intellectual Property Analysis
- BUS 340 Topic 7: Permitted Conduct Decision Paper
- BUS 340 Topic 8: Position Defense Paper
- BUS 352 Topic 5: P Value Dq Response
- BUS 332 Topic 5: Loyalty Program Dq Response
- BUS 390 Topic 5: Value Chain Location DQ
- BUS 317 Topic 5: Relevant Cost Dq Post
BUS 340 Topic 5 questions, answered
Why settle the law first if the question is about ethics?
Because the ethical argument needs to know what it is arguing against. If the conduct were already illegal, the discussion would be about compliance, not ethics. Establishing that the price increase was lawful fixes the ground, and it also prevents the opposite error, reasoning from principle about something a statute has in fact decided. The legal paragraph can be short; it cannot be missing.
Which ethical framework should the post use?
Whichever your prompt names. Where none is named, pick one and apply it properly rather than surveying several: a duty-based view, a consequences-based view, virtue ethics or a stakeholder approach can each carry the argument. Some GCU prompts ask for a Christian worldview perspective as well, and where yours does, that perspective should do analytic work on the specific decision rather than appear as a closing sentiment.
Is the example saying price increases in emergencies are wrong?
It is saying that one composite increase, in one composite state, can be argued as wrong on stated grounds, and it shows the strongest case on the other side. A different set of facts, or a different framework, could reach the opposite judgment. Nothing in it is legal advice about pricing, and real price-gouging rules vary considerably from state to state.
Where can I find a free BUS 340 Topic 5 sample paper?
This page holds the complete post and a reply to Marcus, covering the law, the duty-based argument, the strongest reply, the position and what would change it. Post us the law-versus-ethics prompt from your course for a free worked sample.
What would change the position in BUS 340 Topic 5?
Evidence that the chain used the higher margin to fund emergency shipments that would not otherwise have arrived, with the increase covering little more than that cost.