BUS 390 Topic 5 value chain location DQ example

Global Business Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This BUS 390 Topic 5 sample paper is a discussion post deciding which parts of a medical device value chain should leave Minnesota. It was written for GCU BUS 390, Global Business, catalog code BUS-390, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Business Management. A three-part test comes first: how much know-how would leak, how closely the work must coordinate with engineering and what a failure would cost. Machining and sterilization with packaging move to a contract manufacturer in Costa Rica's device cluster. Design, final release and regulatory filings stay. After-sales support is argued both ways and kept at home for now. The reply asks a classmate which failure they had priced.

CourseBUS 390 Global Business
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeValue chain location discussion post
LengthAbout 500 words, 1 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Business Management
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for BUS 390 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply

Which Parts of a Medical Device Value Chain Should Move to Costa Rica: Six Activities Sorted by One Three-Part Test

Initial Post

My test for whether an activity should leave the home plant has three parts: how much know-how would leak to a partner, how tightly the activity must coordinate with engineering day to day, and what a failure in it would cost the firm. Labor cost only matters once an activity passes all three. I applied the test to a composite Minnesota maker of surgical staplers weighing a move of work to a contract manufacturer in Costa Rica, where a medical device cluster already supplies trained staff and suppliers.

1. Product design stays. It is the firm's core know-how, and handing drawings and test data to a partner risks building a future competitor.

2. Machining of standard components moves. The parts are made to drawings any qualified shop can follow, little know-how leaks, and a bad batch is caught at incoming inspection.

3. Sterilization and packaging move. The cluster already runs validated sterilization lines, and the process is well documented.

4. Final inspection and release stay. A defect that escapes release reaches a surgeon, and the cost of a recall dwarfs any labor saving.

5. Regulatory filings stay. They depend on close contact with design engineers and on the firm's own quality records.

6. After-sales support is the hard case. Handling surgeon questions and returned devices is labor intensive and could be done more cheaply abroad, but complaint handling feeds straight back into design, and a missed complaint trend is a regulatory problem. I would keep it in Minnesota for now and revisit it in eighteen months if the Costa Rica partner handles the moved work with fewer than one nonconformance per thousand units, which would show its quality system is strong enough to trust with feedback from the field.

This matches internalization theory: a firm keeps inside activities where contracting out would expose knowledge it cannot protect by contract (Buckley & Casson, 1976). Mudambi (2008) adds that high-value activities at the two ends of the chain, design and customer contact, tend to stay close to the firm, while the middle is more easily moved.

Reply to Dana

Dana, I agree that cost pressure on device makers is real, and your figure for labor savings on the whole chain is striking. My question is about the sentence where you said every activity could move because Costa Rica's cluster already meets the same quality standards. Which failure had you priced? A late-found defect in a stapler that has already been released could mean a field recall, and the cost of one recall could easily exceed several years of labor savings. If you split the chain and moved only the machining and packaging, would most of the saving remain? Hill and Hult (2019) have a useful section on how firms weigh cost against the risks of losing control, which might help you test the savings claim.

References

Buckley, P. J., & Casson, M. (1976). The future of the multinational enterprise. Macmillan.

Hill, C. W. L., & Hult, G. T. M. (2019). International business: Competing in the global marketplace (12th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Mudambi, R. (2008). Location, control and innovation in knowledge-intensive industries. Journal of Economic Geography, 8(5), 699-725. https://doi.org/10.1093/jeg/lbn024

Reading the GCU BUS 390 Topic 5 instructions

BUS-390 Topic 5 asks students to decide where the activities of a value chain should be located. Many posts answer with a principle and never name an activity. The assignment rewards posts that state a test first, then sort specific activities with a verdict and reason for each, tied to the test rather than to labor cost alone. Students should handle the hardest case honestly, name the evidence that would change its verdict, cite the course reading for its central claim and write a reply that tests one of a classmate's claims instead of simply agreeing.

Inside the BUS 390 Topic 5 example

The initial post takes six activities and gives each a verdict: product design, machining of standard components, sterilization and packaging, final inspection and release, regulatory filings, and after-sales support. The test it applies is stated first, a combination of how much know-how would leak, how tightly the activity must coordinate with engineering, and what a failure would cost. Machining and packaging move to a contract manufacturer in Costa Rica, where a medical device cluster already exists. Design, final release and regulatory work stay, because a defect found late costs far more than any labor saving. After-sales support is argued both ways and kept at home for now, with the condition that would change it. The reply engages a classmate who proposed moving everything, and asks which failure they had priced.

BUS 390 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Instructors marking the value chain post reward a test stated before any verdict. Top posts sort all six activities and tie each verdict back to leakage, coordination or failure cost. Credit goes to arguing after-sales support in both directions and naming the quality figure that would move it. The rubric values citing internalization theory for what it actually claims. The highest level ends with a reply that questions a classmate's savings figure by asking about the cost of a recall. Posts that treat offshoring as all or nothing usually lose marks.

BUS 390 Topic 5 help before you submit

Posts that answer with a principle, such as keeping core competencies at home, and never name an activity lose the most here. A verdict given on labor cost alone misses the reason most activities stay, which is that a failure in them is expensive or the know-how leaks. Sorting activities with no stated test makes every verdict look arbitrary, since a reader cannot tell why packaging moved and inspection did not. Posts that treat offshoring as all or nothing ignore that the question is about specific parts of a value chain. Replies that restate the classmate's point with approval add nothing a grader can credit, while a reply that tests one claim does. Missing citations cost credit in most rubrics, and so does citing a source for something it does not say.

Get a BUS-390 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the BUS-390 Topic 5 discussion question, the DQ rubric from your classroom and any company your section is discussing. A custom example is written to that prompt, with an initial post that sorts activities by a stated test and a reply that challenges one claim, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More BUS 390 papers and BS in Business Management samples

BUS 390 Topic 5 questions, answered

What makes an activity worth keeping at home?

Usually one of three things: the know-how involved would leak to a partner, the activity has to coordinate closely with work that stays, or a failure in it would be expensive to find late. Labor cost pulls the other way. A strong post names which of those applies to each activity rather than treating the whole business as one decision.

Should the post name a real company?

It helps when the prompt allows it, because verdicts about real activities are easier to check. An illustrative company works too, provided the post describes its activities specifically enough to argue about. Posts that stay at the level of firms in general tend to produce principles rather than verdicts, and principles are harder for faculty to credit.

How should the reply to a classmate read?

As engagement with one claim they made. Quote or paraphrase the sentence, say where you agree, then ask a question or add evidence that tests it. Replies that only praise a post rarely meet the substantive reply criterion in many GCU DQ rubrics. One well aimed question usually does more than a paragraph of agreement.

Where can I find a free BUS 390 Topic 5 sample paper?

The complete post is above: the test, the six activities with verdicts, the hard case of after-sales support, the supporting theory and a reply to a classmate. Tell us your firm and activities for a free worked post.

Why does final inspection stay in BUS 390 Topic 5?

A defect that escapes release reaches a surgeon, and one recall could cost more than years of labor savings from moving the work.