| Course | MGT 470 Strategic and Global Human Resource Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Practice classification matrix |
| Length | About 990 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 470 Topic 2
Fixed, Framed or Local: Classifying Twelve HR Practices Across Four Countries With Three Tests and Two Reasons for Every Row
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-470: Strategic and Global Human Resource Management
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Fixed, Framed or Local: Classifying Twelve HR Practices Across Four Countries With Three Tests and Two Reasons for Every Row
Why Classify Practices
Topic 1 placed Keystone Grip Systems' activities on the integration-responsiveness grid and concluded that HR practices should follow the activities they support. This paper applies that conclusion to twelve specific practices across Keystone's four sites in the United States, Mexico, Germany and Japan. Each practice receives one of three verdicts: fixed, meaning the same everywhere; framed, meaning a shared principle with local rules; or local, meaning set by each country. Every row records two reasons, one for why the practice could be global and one for why it could be local, so that the verdict is visibly a choice between them. All details are illustrative.
Three Tests
The verdict for each practice follows from three tests applied in order.
1. Comparison: if the practice's purpose is to compare people or roles across the group, it is fixed. Job grades must be the same everywhere for an engineer moving from Stuttgart to Pittsburgh to know where they stand.
2. Legal or collective control: if a statute, a collective agreement or a works council right sets the practice, it is local. Keystone cannot override German dismissal law or Mexico's statutory profit sharing from headquarters.
3. Market level with shared principle: if a local market sets the level but the principle behind it can be shared, it is framed. Base pay levels differ by country, but the principle that pay should be competitive with the local market can be common.
Research on multinational subsidiaries has found that HR practices are pulled in several directions at once: toward the parent's practices, toward local practices and toward whatever is seen as best practice internationally (Pudelko & Harzing, 2007). These tests are a way of deciding, practice by practice, which pull should win.
The Matrix
Table 1
Twelve Practices, Two Reasons Each and a Verdict
| Practice | Why it could be global | Why it could be local | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Job grades | Needed to compare roles across sites | Local titles differ | Fixed |
| Technician certification | Customers require one service standard | Local training providers differ | Fixed |
| Code of conduct | Customers and law require consistent ethics | Local customs around gifts differ | Fixed |
| Safety standards | One standard protects everyone | Local regulations add requirements | Fixed, plus local additions |
| Performance rating scale | Needed to compare people for global roles | Appraisal principles need works council agreement in Germany | Fixed |
| Base pay level | Shared principle of market competitiveness | Set by local labor markets | Framed |
| Annual incentive | Shared purpose of rewarding results | Profit sharing is statutory in Mexico; works council in Germany | Framed |
| Recruitment channels | Shared employer brand | Local labor market practices differ | Framed |
| Dismissal procedures | Consistent fairness | Set by statute in each country | Local |
| Working time and overtime | Consistent scheduling | Set by statute and agreements | Local |
| Benefits | Consistent value | Statutory and market benefits differ greatly | Local |
| Employee representation | Consistent dialogue | Works councils, unions and statutes differ | Local |
Table 1 applies the tests to twelve practices.
Five practices are fixed, three are framed and four are local. The split reflects the grid from Topic 1: practices that support engineering, quality and service, where integration pressure is high, are fixed; practices governed by national law or labor markets are local; and practices where both pressures operate are framed.
Several rows required judgment. Safety standards are fixed, but local regulations in Mexico and Germany add requirements on top of the group standard, so the verdict records that local additions are allowed. Recruitment channels are framed because Keystone wants a common employer brand, but referral programs, job boards and university relationships differ greatly between Querétaro and Stuttgart.
Why the Reasons Matter
The performance rating scale shows why each row needs both reasons. On the comparison test, the scale should be fixed: Keystone wants to identify high performers across the group for engineering and service leadership roles, and that requires one scale. So the verdict is fixed.
But the local reason does not disappear. In Germany, the works council has a right of co-determination over the principles of employee appraisal. Keystone cannot simply introduce the global scale at its Stuttgart office; it must reach agreement with the works council on how the scale will be applied, what it may be used for and how employees can respond. Recording the local reason alongside the verdict tells the HR team that the fixed scale will need a works agreement in Germany before it can take effect. A verdict without the reason would have left that requirement to be discovered later, probably when the works council objected (Dowling et al., 2017).
The annual incentive is a framed practice for a similar reason. Its purpose, rewarding the results the business needs, is shared. But in Mexico, employers must already share part of their taxable profit with employees by law, and in Germany the principles of a pay system are subject to works council co-determination. Topic 7 redesigns the incentive for those two countries.
Using the Matrix
The matrix gives Keystone's HR leaders a rule for handling future requests. When a site asks to change a fixed practice, the burden is on the site to show why the comparison purpose does not apply. When headquarters wants to standardize a local practice, the burden is on headquarters to show that no statute or agreement controls it. Framed practices are the area for negotiation between the two. Practices most closely tied to local institutions tend to resemble local practice most strongly, so the local verdicts in the matrix are less a choice than a recognition of where Keystone has little room to choose (Rosenzweig & Nohria, 1994).
The matrix is also a communication tool. When a site manager asks why a practice cannot be changed, HR can point to the row, the two reasons and the test that decided the verdict. That is more persuasive, and more consistent across sites, than an answer that depends on who in Pittsburgh happens to take the call.
References
Dowling, P. J., Festing, M., & Engle, A. D., Sr. (2017). International human resource management (7th ed.). Cengage Learning.
Pudelko, M., & Harzing, A.-W. (2007). Country-of-origin, localization, or dominance effect? An empirical investigation of HRM practices in foreign subsidiaries. Human Resource Management, 46(4), 535-559. https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.20181
Rosenzweig, P. M., & Nohria, N. (1994). Influences on human resource management practices in multinational corporations. Journal of International Business Studies, 25(2), 229-251. https://doi.org/10.1057/palgrave.jibs.8490199
The MGT-470 Topic 2 assignment instructions
The Topic 2 instructions in MGT-470 ask students to decide which HR practices a multinational should standardize and which it should adapt. Declaring practices global or local by preference, without stated criteria, will not withstand challenge. The assignment rewards a matrix built from explicit tests applied in a fixed order, with reasons on both sides of every row so the verdict is visibly a choice. Students should explain how a verdict can still carry local obligations, as when a fixed practice requires agreement from employee representatives, and show how the matrix guides future requests from sites or headquarters by placing the burden of proof on whoever wants to change a practice's tier.
How this MGT 470 Topic 2 example is built
The paper opens by linking the classification to the grid from Topic 1. Three tests are set out in order, with research on the pulls acting on subsidiary practices. Table 1 lists twelve practices with a reason they could be global, a reason they could be local and a verdict. A short summary counts five fixed, three framed and four local. A section uses the rating scale and the incentive to show why both reasons matter, including works council co-determination and statutory profit sharing. The closing section explains how the matrix assigns the burden of proof for future requests.
MGT 470 Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Instructors grading the matrix reward tests that are stated before any verdict and applied consistently. Strong papers give a real reason on both sides of each row, so readers can see the trade-off rather than a label. Credit goes to recognizing that a fixed verdict may still carry local obligations, such as works council agreement, and that legal and collective controls leave little room for choice. The rubric values research cited accurately on why subsidiary practices vary. The highest band explains how the matrix will be used when sites or headquarters ask to change a practice. Matrices that assign verdicts without stated criteria usually lose marks.
MGT 470 Topic 2 help before you submit
A verdict carrying only one reason is where most matrices forfeit their credit. A row marked local because countries differ, with no statement of what would make the practice global, gives the reader nothing to weigh. Papers classifying everything as global in the name of consistency have not met the German works council or Mexican labor law, while papers classifying everything as local cannot explain why the group needs a job grade system at all. Sorting practices without stating the tests, or applying them in no stated order, produces verdicts nobody can reproduce. Treating a works council right as a cultural preference misreads a statutory requirement. Missing the difference between a practice's definition and its introduction, as with the rating scale, collapses two separate questions into one and usually gets both wrong.
Get an MGT-470 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-470 Topic 2 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the organization or practice list the assignment provides. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the classification tests stated and ordered, both reasons given for each practice, framed practices specified element by element and the hardest case argued in full, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 470 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- MGT 470 Topic 1: Integration Responsiveness Analysis
- MGT 470 Topic 3: Statutory Dismissal Comparison
- MGT 470 Topic 4: Expatriate Package Analysis
- MGT 470 Topic 5: Local Legitimacy Dq Post
- MGT 470 Topic 6: International Staffing Decision Analysis
- MGT 470 Topic 7: Two Country Incentive Redesign
- MGT 470 Topic 8: Global Framework Exception Register
- MGT 465 Topic 2: Grievance Step Record Analysis
- BUS 317 Topic 2: Statement Reading Memo
- MGT 460 Topic 2: Headcount Demand Forecast
- BUS 332 Topic 2: Customer Lifetime Value Calculation
MGT 470 Topic 2 questions, answered
What does framed mean in this matrix?
A framed practice shares its principle across the group while letting each country set the level or mechanism. Base pay is the common example: every site may position pay against the same market percentile for each grade, while the actual figures follow each local market. Framing is how the example avoids choosing between uniformity and full local freedom when neither fits the practice.
Why does a works council affect the rating scale?
German works constitution law gives works councils co-determination rights over general appraisal principles, so a new rating system generally cannot be introduced at a German plant without the council's agreement. That does not make the scale local, since its definitions can stay identical, but it changes how and when it arrives. The example treats this as coursework analysis, not legal advice.
Can a practice move between categories?
Yes, when the strategy or the law changes. If the firm began selling differently in each country, service standards might shift from fixed to framed; if a country changed its dismissal law, the local rows would need rewriting. The example closes by listing the practices most likely to move, which keeps the matrix tied to the business rather than frozen as policy.
Where can I find a free MGT 470 Topic 2 sample paper?
The twelve-practice matrix appears here with its three tests, the reasons on both sides, why the reasons matter and how the matrix is used. Describe the practices you need to classify and a free matrix can be built around them.
Why is the rating scale fixed in MGT 470 Topic 2?
The group needs one scale to compare people for global roles. In Germany, though, the works council must agree on appraisal principles, so the fixed scale still needs a works agreement there.