| Course | MGT 470 Strategic and Global Human Resource Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Staffing decision analysis |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 470 Topic 6
A Default Nobody Chose: Staffing Three International Posts by What Each One Needs Rather Than by Sending Pittsburgh Managers Abroad
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-470: Strategic and Global Human Resource Management
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Default Nobody Chose: Staffing Three International Posts by What Each One Needs Rather Than by Sending Pittsburgh Managers Abroad
The Default
Every head of an international site that Keystone Grip Systems has appointed in its twenty-year history has come from Pittsburgh. No one decided this as a policy. It happened because Pittsburgh managers knew the product and the leadership team knew them. Perlmutter (1969) described this pattern as ethnocentric: key positions abroad filled by people from headquarters, on the assumption that home-country managers and methods are best. The pattern can make sense for a young firm with few experienced managers abroad. For Keystone, with established sites in Mexico, Germany and Japan, it has become a default that nobody has examined.
Three posts need filling in the next year: general manager of the Querétaro assembly and service center, head of the Nagoya sales and service office and engineering lead at the Stuttgart office. This analysis staffs each by what the post most needs. All figures are illustrative.
Three Staffing Options
Multinational firms fill posts abroad from three pools: parent-country nationals, sent from headquarters; host-country nationals, from the country where the post is; and third-country nationals, from another country where the firm operates (Dowling et al., 2017). Each pool brings different strengths, and which pool fits depends on the demands of the particular post.
Each pool has typical strengths. Parent-country nationals bring knowledge of headquarters, its products and its expectations, and they make coordination easier. Host-country nationals bring language, local networks and an understanding of local law and customs, usually at lower cost. Third-country nationals can bring specific expertise developed elsewhere in the firm and help build a more international management group.
Querétaro General Manager
The Querétaro general manager's main challenges are local. The plant has a unionized workforce, local suppliers and relationships with state economic development officials. Success depends on legitimacy with those groups, on understanding Mexican labor law and on the ability to negotiate with the union in Spanish and within local norms. A host-country national with experience running a Mexican manufacturing site would bring all of that.
Headquarters' concern is financial control: the Querétaro center is growing quickly, and Pittsburgh wants confidence that its accounts follow group standards. That concern can be met without making the general manager a parent-country national. The analysis proposes a Mexican general manager supported by a finance controller from Pittsburgh for two years, who would set up group reporting and train a local successor.
The arrangement also signals something to the plant's employees and union. A Mexican general manager shows that leadership positions are open to local talent, which can strengthen retention among supervisors who might otherwise see no path upward.
Nagoya Office Head
The Nagoya office exists to win and keep business with Japanese automakers. Those relationships depend on long-term trust, fluent Japanese and an understanding of how purchasing decisions are made inside Japanese firms. Keystone's past Pittsburgh appointees in Nagoya spent most of their time learning these things and left just as they were becoming effective. Only a host-country national can bring fluency and established relationships from the start, so the post should go to a Japanese manager.
Keystone's concern about the Nagoya post has been control: a Japanese manager may build relationships that belong to the manager rather than to the company. That risk can be managed by regular visits from Pittsburgh's sales leadership and by recording customer relationships in the firm's systems, rather than by appointing someone without the fluency to do the job.
Stuttgart Engineering Lead
The Stuttgart engineering lead must adapt Keystone's gripper platform to the requirements of German automakers, which are about to launch a new product line. The most relevant experience in the company belongs to an engineer in Querétaro who led the platform's adaptation for a Mexican automotive plant during the last product launch and knows its technical history in detail. Neither a Pittsburgh engineer, who has not done that adaptation work, nor a German hire, who does not know the platform, would bring the same knowledge.
The analysis proposes a third-country assignment: the Querétaro engineer moves to Stuttgart for two years. Third-country assignments are still uncommon in many firms, but they can bring specific expertise where it is most needed and build an international pool of managers who are not all from headquarters (Collings et al., 2009). Because the engineer will need a role to return to, the analysis names it before departure: lead engineer for the next platform generation, based in Querétaro.
The German works council will expect to be informed about the appointment, and the engineer will need a German work permit, which typically takes several weeks. Neither is an obstacle, but both should be planned for so that the engineer arrives in time for the product launch.
Costs
Table 1
Annual Cost of Recommended Staffing Against the Default
| Post | Recommended choice | Annual cost of recommendation | Annual cost of a Pittsburgh assignee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Querétaro general manager | Host-country national, plus a Pittsburgh controller for two years | About $95,000 for the manager, plus about $200,000 for the controller in years 1 and 2 | About $240,000 |
| Nagoya office head | Host-country national | About $170,000 | About $280,000 |
| Stuttgart engineering lead | Third-country national from Querétaro | About $150,000 including assignment allowances | About $230,000 |
Table 1 compares the annual cost of each choice with the default of sending a Pittsburgh manager.
In each case the recommended choice costs less than a Pittsburgh assignee, but the main argument is not cost. It is that each post's most important need, local legitimacy, client relationships or specific platform knowledge, is best met by someone other than a Pittsburgh manager.
Recommendation
Keystone should appoint a Mexican general manager in Querétaro with a temporary Pittsburgh controller, a Japanese head in Nagoya and a Querétaro engineer as Stuttgart engineering lead, with the engineer's return role agreed before departure. It should also adopt a simple rule for future appointments: before a site head is named, the leadership team writes down what the post most needs and which pool best supplies it. That one step would turn an unexamined default into a decision.
References
Collings, D. G., Scullion, H., & Dowling, P. J. (2009). Global staffing: A review and thematic research agenda. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 20(6), 1253-1272. https://doi.org/10.1080/09585190902909806
Dowling, P. J., Festing, M., & Engle, A. D., Sr. (2017). International human resource management (7th ed.). Cengage Learning.
Perlmutter, H. V. (1969). The tortuous evolution of the multinational corporation. Columbia Journal of World Business, 4(1), 9-18.
MGT 470 Topic 6 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 6 instructions for MGT-470 ask students to decide how to staff key international positions. Choosing headquarters managers by default, or local managers by default, skips the analysis. The assignment rewards naming the firm's current pattern, describing each post by what it most needs and choosing among parent-country, host-country and third-country nationals on that basis. Students should address headquarters' legitimate concerns, such as financial control, without defaulting to an expatriate, cost each choice against the alternative and plan the return of anyone sent abroad. A simple rule for future appointments turns the analysis into lasting practice.
How the MGT-470 Topic 6 example is put together
The paper opens by naming the ethnocentric default using Perlmutter. The three staffing pools are described. Each post is analyzed in its own section: Querétaro's need for local legitimacy, met by a host-country manager with a temporary Pittsburgh controller; Nagoya's need for relationships and fluency, met by a Japanese manager; and Stuttgart's need for platform knowledge, met by a Querétaro engineer on a third-country assignment with a named return role. Table 1 compares annual costs with the default. A recommendation adds a rule that each post's needs be written down before an appointment. Practical steps for each post, such as work permits and visits from headquarters, are noted.
Where the marks sit in the MGT 470 Topic 6 rubric
Instructors grading the staffing analysis reward a pattern named and questioned before any choice is made. Strong papers describe each post by what it requires and choose a staffing pool to match, citing the staffing literature accurately. Credit goes to addressing headquarters' concerns without defaulting to an expatriate and to considering third-country nationals where they bring specific knowledge. The rubric values costs compared on the same basis and a return role planned before departure. The highest band proposes a practice that prevents the default from returning. Analyses that staff every post the same way usually land in the lower bands. Attention to practical details such as permits and works council notice also counts.
Common MGT 470 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them
One approach applied to every post is the commonest reason staffing analyses score low. A paper recommending host-country nationals throughout because they are cheaper and local has ignored the post where platform knowledge matters more than local ties. Recommending home-country managers everywhere repeats the default the topic asks writers to question. Candidates compared on cost alone miss what each post exists to do, and candidates compared on fit alone never show the price of the choice. Selection based only on technical record overlooks the family and adjustment factors that Tung's research placed among the main reasons assignments end early. Analyses citing very high expatriate failure rates as fact overlook Harzing's argument that those figures rest on weak evidence. Assignments with no return role planned leave the firm likely to lose the person it just developed.
Get an MGT-470 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-470 Topic 6 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the roles, countries or organization the case describes. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the current orientation named, each post's needs stated, candidate types compared on fit and cost, selection and preparation planned and a return role set, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 470 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- MGT 470 Topic 1: Integration Responsiveness Analysis
- MGT 470 Topic 2: Practice Classification Matrix
- MGT 470 Topic 3: Statutory Dismissal Comparison
- MGT 470 Topic 4: Expatriate Package Analysis
- MGT 470 Topic 5: Local Legitimacy Dq Post
- MGT 470 Topic 7: Two Country Incentive Redesign
- MGT 470 Topic 8: Global Framework Exception Register
- MGT 465 Topic 6: Workplace Investigation Report
- BUS 317 Topic 6: Budget Commitment Review
- MGT 460 Topic 6: Succession Bench Review
- BUS 332 Topic 6: Service Recovery Evaluation
MGT 470 Topic 6 questions, answered
What are Perlmutter's staffing orientations?
Howard Perlmutter described ethnocentric, polycentric and geocentric orientations in multinational management, later joined by a regiocentric category in work with David Heenan. Ethnocentric firms fill key posts with home-country nationals, polycentric firms let host nationals run subsidiaries, and geocentric firms seek the best person regardless of nationality. Many firms mix orientations, and the example shows its three decisions producing a mix.
What did Tung find about expatriate failure?
Rosalie Tung's surveys of multinationals found that American firms most often cited the spouse's inability to adjust, followed by the manager's own difficulties, as reasons assignments ended early. Her work helped move selection beyond technical competence. Later researchers, Anne-Wil Harzing among them, questioned the very high failure rates often quoted alongside such findings, and the example cites both.
Why plan the return before the assignment starts?
Because the return is where many firms lose the value of an assignment. A returning engineer whose former role was filled, and whose new skills have no obvious use, has every reason to take them elsewhere. Naming the return role in advance gives the assignment a clear purpose for both sides and lets the home site plan for what the returnee brings back.
Where can I find a free MGT 470 Topic 6 sample paper?
The staffing analysis appears here in full, with the default, the three pools, each post's needs and choice, the cost table and the recommendation. Describe the posts you need to fill, and a free analysis can be written for them.
Why a third-country national for Stuttgart in MGT 470 Topic 6?
The engineer in Querétaro led the platform's adaptation during the last product launch, knowledge neither a Pittsburgh engineer nor a German hire has, so a two-year assignment brings it where it is needed.