| Course | MGT 820 Using Business Analytics for Competitive Advantage |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Decision rights map |
| Length | About 1,070 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 820 Topic 3
Analysis That Arrives After the Quote: Mapping Who Makes the Four Decisions a Freight Carrier's Pricing Analytics Was Funded to Change, and When
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
MGT-820: Using Business Analytics for Competitive Advantage
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Analysis That Arrives After the Quote: Mapping Who Makes the Four Decisions a Freight Carrier's Pricing Analytics Was Funded to Change, and When
The Question
Analytics creates advantage only through decisions that change. A model that is accurate but reaches no one in time to alter a commitment produces reports, not results. Sharma et al. (2014) make the same point in their research agenda: the value of business analytics depends on how insights are taken up in decision-making processes, not on the insights alone. This paper applies that idea to Prairie Line Freight, a composite less-than-truckload carrier with 41 terminals in the central United States, which two years ago approved a 3.2 million dollar pricing analytics program. The funding case named four decisions the program would improve: lane rates, acceptance of low-margin freight, terminal capacity planning and customer renewal terms. The map below asks, for each decision, who makes it, when, and whether the analysis reaches that person before the decision is made.
Method
Each decision was traced in three ways. The approval documents identified what the program promised for each decision. Quote records for a sample of 400 shipments over two months showed when rates were set and by whom. Interviews with the composite pricing director, two terminal managers and four sales representatives described how each decision is actually made and what the representatives do with model recommendations. The map records what these sources show rather than what the organization chart says.
The Decision Rights Map
Table 1
Four Funded Decisions by Owner, Timing and Arrival of Analysis, Illustrative
| Decision | Owner | When made | Analysis arrives before? | Override rules | Observed change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lane rates on spot quotes | Sales representative | During the customer call | No: model price posts in the system about four hours later | Any override, no reason recorded | Little: quoted rates track the old tariff |
| Acceptance of low-margin freight | Sales representative | At the quote | No: margin estimate arrives with the overnight report | None needed | None: low-margin share unchanged |
| Terminal capacity | Regional operations director | Quarterly planning meeting | Yes: forecast in the meeting pack | Director decides, notes reasons | Moderate: two terminals rebalanced |
| Customer renewal terms | Pricing director with account manager | Annual contract review | Yes: account profitability report | Pricing director approves | Strong: discounts cut on 30 unprofitable accounts |
Table 1 sets out the four decisions with five columns: who holds the right to make the decision, when it is made, whether the model's output arrives before that moment, the rules for overriding the model and what change has been observed since the program began.
Findings
The map divides the program cleanly into two halves. For terminal capacity and renewal terms, decisions made on a planning calendar by managers who receive the analysis beforehand, the program has changed what the carrier does. Renewal reviews in particular have used account profitability reports to reduce discounts on about 30 accounts that were losing money, which the pricing director credits with roughly 1.4 million dollars of added annual margin.
For lane rates and freight acceptance, the program describes decisions already taken. Sales representatives quote spot rates on the telephone, usually within minutes of a customer's request, and accept or decline freight in the same call. The model's recommended price and margin estimate are calculated in an overnight batch and posted the next morning, or about four hours after an intraday request. By then the shipment is booked. Representatives told interviewers that they look at the recommendations later, if at all, to see how they did. In the quote sample, rates moved toward the model recommendation in only 9 percent of cases, and the share of low-margin freight was unchanged from before the program. These two decisions account for about 70 percent of the revenue the program was meant to influence.
Knowledge and Rights Placed Together
Jensen and Meckling (1995) argued that decision rights work best when they are placed with the people who hold the relevant knowledge, and that organizations must either move knowledge to the decision maker or move the decision right to the person with the knowledge. They distinguish general knowledge, which is cheap to transfer, from specific knowledge, which is costly to transfer, such as a representative's sense of a customer's alternatives. Brickley et al. (1995) extend the argument by treating decision rights, performance measures and rewards as a linked system that must be designed together.
At Prairie Line, lane pricing involves both kinds of knowledge. The model holds general knowledge about lane costs, network balance and historical yields, which can be transferred instantly if the system delivers it. The representative holds specific knowledge about the customer on the phone. The carrier has placed the right with the representative, which is defensible, but it has failed to move the general knowledge to the representative at the moment of decision. And because representatives are paid on revenue rather than margin, the performance measure points away from the model even when the model is consulted.
The Exploration Objection
The analytics team argues that a map like this undervalues exploratory work, which pays off in ways no one can anticipate when the program is funded. The team points to an unplanned discovery that certain lanes were consistently underpriced on weekends. The objection deserves a fair answer. Exploration has value and should have a budget line of its own. But it cannot be the basis of a competitive advantage claim for a program funded against four named decisions, because its payoffs are unpredictable and, once found, easily copied by any carrier who looks at the same data. The weekend finding itself will matter only when it reaches the person quoting a weekend rate.
Recommendation
The carrier should not invest in a better model. The map shows the existing model is not reaching the decisions it was built for. Instead, it should reassign one decision right and support it with two changes around it. Spot quotes above a set size, about 15 percent of shipments and 45 percent of spot revenue, should move from the representative alone to a shared right: the representative still quotes, with the model price on screen during the call, but any price more than 10 percent below it needs a pricing analyst's approval before it is given, which an on-call analyst can supply within minutes. The overnight batch should be replaced with a pricing service that responds during the call. Representatives' compensation should include a margin component. The map should then be redrawn after two quarters, using the same quote sample method, to see whether the timing column has changed.
References
Brickley, J. A., Smith, C. W., & Zimmerman, J. L. (1995). The economics of organizational architecture. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 8(2), 19-31. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-6622.1995.tb00284.x
Jensen, M. C., & Meckling, W. H. (1995). Specific and general knowledge, and organizational structure. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 8(2), 4-18. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-6622.1995.tb00283.x
Sharma, R., Mithas, S., & Kankanhalli, A. (2014). Transforming decision-making processes: A research agenda for understanding the impact of business analytics on organisations. European Journal of Information Systems, 23(4), 433-441. https://doi.org/10.1057/ejis.2014.17
What the MGT 820 Topic 3 instructions ask for
Topic 3 of MGT-820 asks doctoral learners to connect analytics to the decisions it is supposed to change. The brief treats a model as worthless for advantage unless its output reaches a decision maker in time and carries weight. A paper meets the prompt when it lists the decisions an analytics program was funded to improve, identifies who holds each decision right, records when each decision is made and whether analysis arrives beforehand, and notes the override rules. Learners should draw on organizational economics about matching decision rights with knowledge, answer the argument that exploratory analytics pays off unpredictably, and recommend a change to who decides or how the analysis reaches them, then say how to check it.
How this MGT 820 Topic 3 example is built
The finished map is a table with an argument wrapped around it. Its rows are the decisions the carrier's analytics program was approved to improve: lane rates, acceptance of low-margin freight, terminal capacity and customer renewal terms. Its columns record who holds the right to make each one, when it is made, whether a model's output reaches that person before commitment, and whether the person can override it without explanation. The pattern that emerges is that sales representatives quote most rates before the analysis arrives, so the program describes decisions already taken. The paper draws on Jensen and Meckling's argument that decision rights function best where the relevant knowledge sits, and asks whether the carrier has put them in the wrong place. An exploration-value objection is then answered.
Reading the MGT 820 Topic 3 rubric
The rubric rewards a map built from evidence of timing. An Excellent paper takes its rows from the program's funding case, traces each decision through quote records and interviews, and fills a column showing whether the analysis arrives before the commitment. Credit goes to the finding that analysis reaches some decisions after they are made, and to sizing how much revenue those decisions represent. Faculty look for Jensen and Meckling applied as a general argument about knowledge and authority, together with attention to incentives. Strong papers answer the exploration objection by giving it a budget without counting it as advantage. The highest band recommends a specific reassignment instead of a better model.
MGT 820 Topic 3 help before you submit
A map with decisions and no owners is the version that loses the most ground. Listing lane pricing as a decision analytics improves, without saying who sets the rate or when, leaves the reader unable to tell whether the analysis could have reached it. Papers that treat a dashboard viewed by managers as a decision changed confuse attention with action, a distinction graders here typically hold to. Timing is the column students skip, yet it is where most programs are found describing commitments already made. Citing Jensen and Meckling as though they wrote about analytics misattributes a general argument about knowledge and authority. Recommendations to build better models, when the finding is that the right people never see them, answer a question the map has already closed.
Get an MGT-820 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-820 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the company or scenario your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with every decision traced to its owner and timing, override rules recorded and one reassignment argued, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More MGT 820 papers and DBA samples
- MGT 820 Topic 1: Analytics Advantage Thesis
- MGT 820 Topic 2: Data Asset Inimitability Analysis
- MGT 820 Topic 4: Analytics Routines Assessment
- MGT 820 Topic 5: Rival Imitation Timeline
- MGT 820 Topic 6: Reporting Gain Dq Response
- MGT 820 Topic 7: Decision Anchored Business Case
- MGT 820 Topic 8: Advantage Durability Assessment
- MGT 825 Topic 3: Enterprise Risk Liability Paper
- MGT 805 Topic 3: Coordination Cost Quantification
- MGT 830 Topic 3: Backfire Case Critique
- DBA 965 Topic 3: Interpretation Boundary Memo
MGT 820 Topic 3 questions, answered
Why map decision rights in an analytics course?
Because analysis produces advantage only when it changes what someone decides, and that depends on who decides, when, and whether they can ignore the output. A strong model feeding a meeting that has already committed changes nothing. The map makes that visible row by row, which is why many sections place it after the data asset and before any investment case.
What if the analysis is exploratory and no decision is known yet?
Then it can be justified as exploration, with its own modest budget and a review date, and it should not be presented as a source of advantage. The example grants that open-ended work sometimes finds something valuable. It declines to count that possibility as a capability a rival cannot copy, since a competitor can fund exploration too.
Is it acceptable to use an interview as a source in this paper?
In the example the pricing director is a composite, identified as such, and the interview is a device for tracing timing. In your own paper, follow the prompt: some sections want published cases only, while others accept an organization the writer knows, de-identified. Whatever the source, state where each row's timing came from so the table can be verified.
Where can I find a free MGT 820 Topic 3 sample paper?
Every part of the freight carrier map appears here: the question, the method, the five-column table, the findings, the knowledge and rights section, the exploration objection and the recommendation. Tell us which analytics program your case describes and a free map can be drawn for it.
Why did the analytics miss lane rates in MGT 820 Topic 3?
Representatives quote spot rates during the customer call, while the model's recommended price arrives in a batch about four hours later, after the freight is booked. Representatives are also paid on revenue rather than margin.