| Course | FIN 504 Finance Principles |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Valuation recommendation |
| Length | About 830 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 504 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Board of Directors
From: Chief Financial Officer
Date: [Date]
Re: Proposed acquisition of the regional ductwork fabricator
Recommendation
Offer 50 million dollars for the regional ductwork fabricator, and walk away above 56 million. The seller is asking 55 million. Our estimate of the business's value on its own is about 51.7 million, within a range of about 49 to 55 million, and the cost savings from combining it with our operations add value we should share only in part. This memo explains how we reached those figures and what they depend on.
What We Valued
We valued the fabricator by discounting the free cash flow it is expected to generate: cash from operations after taxes and after the investment needed to sustain and grow the business, the cash an owner could actually take out (Koller et al., 2020). Management's forecast, which we reviewed against five years of its results, shows free cash flow rising from 3.0 million dollars next year to 4.1 million in year 5 as two new contractor accounts mature. After year 5 we assume growth of 2.5 percent a year, close to long-run nominal growth in construction spending. We discounted at 9.5 percent, above our own 7.71 percent cost of capital, because the fabricator is smaller and more dependent on a few customers than we are, and its risk, not ours, sets the rate.
The Estimate
The five years of forecast cash flows are worth about 13.6 million dollars today. The value of all cash flows after year 5, the terminal value, is 4.1 x 1.025 / (0.095 minus 0.025), about 60.0 million at year 5, or about 38.1 million today. The total is about 51.7 million dollars. About three quarters of that value lies beyond year 5, so the long-run assumptions matter more than the details of the forecast.
Table 1
Standalone Value in Millions of Dollars Under Alternative Assumptions
| Discount rate | Growth 2.0% | Growth 2.5% | Growth 3.0% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8.5% | 56.7 | 60.5 | 65.0 |
| 9.5% | 49.0 | 51.7 | 54.8 |
| 10.5% | 43.1 | 45.1 | 47.4 |
How Much to Trust It
The table shows how the estimate moves. A one point change in the discount rate moves value by about 6 to 10 million dollars; half a point of long-run growth moves it by about 2 to 4 million. The reasonable range is about 49 to 55 million. Two checks support the center of that range. Comparable fabricators have recently sold for around 8 times their operating earnings before depreciation, which on the fabricator's 6.5 million dollars gives 52 million. And research on completed transactions finds that discounted cash flow estimates built this way track the prices eventually paid reasonably well (Kaplan & Ruback, 1995).
The Synergies and Who Should Get Them
Combining the fabricator with our heat pump line would save about 0.8 million dollars a year from year 2 onward, mainly from shared purchasing of sheet metal and one less delivery fleet, after about 1.0 million of integration cost in year 1. At the same rate and growth, those savings are worth about 9.5 million dollars today. We do not recommend paying the seller for them in full. Acquirers who pay away expected synergies in the purchase price commonly fail to earn them back, because savings arrive later and smaller than planned (Sirower, 1997). Our walk-away price of 56 million gives the seller about half the synergy value on top of standalone value, which is enough to compete with a buyer who has no synergies and keeps the rest for our shareholders if integration goes as planned.
What Would Change the Recommendation
We would revisit the price if due diligence finds that either of the two new contractor accounts lacks a signed multiyear agreement, since those accounts drive the forecast's growth; if cash flow instead stayed flat at 3.0 million, the standalone value would fall to about 39 million. We would also revisit it if interest rates rise enough to lift the discount rate a full point. Conversely, a binding supply agreement with a national homebuilder, which the seller says is under negotiation, would justify a higher offer, but only once it is signed.
Funding and Integration
We would fund the purchase from 20 million dollars of cash and a new term loan for the balance, which keeps our debt within the range our lenders and the rating agencies expect. The integration cost of about 1.0 million is already deducted in the synergy estimate. The two savings that justify the walk-away price, shared sheet metal purchasing and the consolidated delivery fleet, would be assigned to named managers with quarterly targets, and the board would receive a report against those targets at each meeting during the first two years.
Decision Requested
We ask the board to approve an opening offer of 50 million dollars and authority to negotiate up to 56 million, subject to due diligence on the two contractor accounts. Above 56 million, the acquisition would transfer most of its value to the seller, and we would recommend continuing to buy ductwork from the fabricator as a supplier instead.
References
Kaplan, S. N., & Ruback, R. S. (1995). The valuation of cash flow forecasts: An empirical analysis. Journal of Finance, 50(4), 1059-1093. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1995.tb04050.x
Koller, T., Goedhart, M., & Wessels, D. (2020). Valuation: Measuring and managing the value of companies (7th ed.). Wiley.
Sirower, M. L. (1997). The synergy trap: How companies lose the acquisition game. Free Press.
The FIN-504 Topic 8 assignment instructions
Topic 8 of FIN-504 asks MBA students to value a business and recommend action. Strong recommendations lead with the decision, explain what was valued and at what rate, and show how the estimate moves with the discount rate and growth. Students should check the result against another method, treat synergies separately from standalone value, name what would change the answer and state the decision requested. The memo should also state the decision requested of the board and the alternative if the price is not met. Funding and integration should be addressed briefly, since the board will ask how the deal is paid for and who delivers the savings.
How this FIN 504 Topic 8 example is built
The finished example separates the analysis from the document that carries it. The valuation itself uses the tools the course built, discounting projected flows at the cost of capital established earlier, with the projections stated as assumptions rather than presented as facts. A range appears rather than a single figure, because a point estimate implies a precision the inputs cannot support. The recommendation then leads, since a management reader wants the conclusion before the method. Sensitivity is reported in the terms a decision maker cares about, naming which assumption would have to be wrong, and by how much, for the recommendation to reverse. Technical detail sits in an appendix rather than in the argument.
FIN 504 Topic 8 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward a valuation that ends in a price the board can act on. An Excellent paper discounts free cash flow at the target's own 9.5 percent rate, following Koller and colleagues. Credit goes to a sensitivity grid and a check against a trading multiple, with Kaplan and Ruback on accuracy. The rubric values synergies valued separately and shared only in part, citing Sirower. Strong papers name the contract accounts that would lower the price. Top marks go to a walk-away price and an alternative. Papers that name the specific diligence finding that would lower the price, and the value without it, show the valuation used to manage risk. Credit also goes to an alternative such as continuing as a customer of the target.
FIN 504 Topic 8 help before you submit
Reports written for the marker rather than for management are the shortfall this topic targets, and the symptom is a document opening with method and reaching a conclusion on the last page. A second failure is a single point valuation presented with confidence, which overstates what any projection supports and invites a challenge the paper cannot answer. Papers lose marks for assumptions buried inside calculations, since an input nobody can locate cannot be challenged by the person the document was written for. Omitting sensitivity leaves a decision maker unable to judge how much the recommendation depends on a forecast. Recommendations with no next step and no owner leave the document without a purpose.
Get a FIN-504 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-504 Topic 8 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the company or project your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the recommendation leading, a value range rather than a point, assumptions surfaced and sensitivity reported in decision terms, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More FIN 504 papers and MBA samples
- FIN 504 Topic 1: Time Value of Money Problem Set
- FIN 504 Topic 2: Bond and Stock Valuation
- FIN 504 Topic 3: Risk and Required Return Analysis
- FIN 504 Topic 4: Cost of Capital Build
- FIN 504 Topic 5: Capital Budgeting Analysis
- FIN 504 Topic 6: Project Ranking Analysis
- FIN 504 Topic 7: Capital Structure Analysis
- ECN 601 Topic 8: Trade and Exchange Rate Analysis
- HRM 635 Topic 8: Talent Investment Business Case
- BUS 660 Topic 8: Project Scheduling Recommendation
- HRM 640 Topic 8: Competing Proposal Executive Case
FIN 504 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why lead with the recommendation?
Because the audience decides rather than marks. A management reader wants to know what you are advising and how confident you are, then reads far enough into the reasoning to satisfy themselves. A document that builds toward a conclusion in the final paragraph works for an examiner and fails for the reader it is nominally addressed to, which is exactly the distinction this topic assesses.
Should I give a single value or a range?
A range, with the assumptions that produce each end stated. Valuations rest on projections, and a single figure carried to two decimal places implies a precision nobody has. Presenting a range and naming what would move the answer toward each end is more useful to a decision maker and more honest about what the analysis established.
How much technical detail belongs in the document?
Enough to establish credibility and no more, with the rest in an appendix. A management reader needs to know what method you used, what it rests on and how sensitive it is. They do not need every discounting step. Putting the working somewhere referenced rather than in the argument keeps both audiences served, and most rubrics reward the structure explicitly.
Where can I find a free FIN 504 Topic 8 sample paper?
The board memo appears in full: the recommendation, what was valued, the estimate, how much to trust it, synergies, what would change it, funding and integration, and the decision requested. Send your valuation case and a board memo follows at no charge.
Why walk away above 56 million in FIN 504 Topic 8?
Standalone value is about 51.7 million. Paying 56 million gives the seller about half the 9.5 million of synergies, and paying more would transfer most of the deal's value to the seller.